Intrinsic Value

The intrinsic value of American Integrity Insurance Group Inc (AII) under the Base Case is 22.8 USD per share. Compared with the current market price of 28.6 USD, the stock appears Overvalued by 20% .

The intrinsic value is calculated using valuation multiples.

Do our valuations actually work? See backtest results .

AII Intrinsic Value
$22.8
Overvaluation 20%
Intrinsic Value
Price $28.6

We don’t have enough historical valuation data to make this comparison.

Alert me when AII is below its intrinsic value
Today $18.24 · 36.2% below the current price
Alternatives to AII

Fundamental Analysis

What American Integrity Insurance Does

Insurance Financials

American Integrity Insurance Group writes and services residential property insurance, mainly homeowners policies in Florida and nearby coastal markets. It sells coverage through independent insurance agents, then collects premiums and pays claims when policyholders have damage from events like storms, fire, or water loss. The company’s job in the insurance chain is to take on that risk and manage it with underwriting, claims handling, and reinsurance support.

Headquarters
United States of America US
Employees
313
IPO date
May 8, 2025
Read the full company overview
View Company Overview
Financials

Balance Sheet

Efficiency

Wall St Price Targets

Shareholder Returns

Competitive Landscape

Recent Events

Latest Earnings Call

Q3 2026 · November 11, 2026

American Integrity is growing its voluntary business while emphasizing disciplined risk selection and retaining more of the economics it creates.

Open the earnings call
EPS
$1.44
Expected
$0.67
Surprise
+114.9%
Stock, day of the call
+4.5%
View Earnings Call

American Integrity Insurance insiders made their first purchases in five years

Insider trading · Last trade on Oct 14, 2026

Sold $21.9m 2 insiders
Bought $2.5m 4 insiders
Trades by date
Open insider trading

Past 12 months

Continue AII Research

Decided on American Integrity Insurance? Get an email when AII reaches the price you’d buy at. Free with an account.

What is the Intrinsic Value of one AII stock?

The intrinsic value for American Integrity Insurance Group Inc (AII) under the Base Case is 22.8 USD.

Is AII stock undervalued or overvalued?

Compared with the current market price of 28.6 USD, the stock appears Overvalued by 20% .

How reliable are our estimates? See how past valuations played out
Back to Top