Caseys General Stores Inc
NASDAQ:CASY

Watchlist Manager
Caseys General Stores Inc Logo
Caseys General Stores Inc
NASDAQ:CASY
Watchlist
Price: 563.15 USD 1.41% Market Closed
Market Cap: 20.9B USD

Intrinsic Value

The intrinsic value of one CASY stock under the Base Case scenario is 320.34 USD. Compared to the current market price of 563.15 USD, Caseys General Stores Inc is Overvalued by 43%.

The Intrinsic Value is calculated as the average of DCF and Relative values:

CASY Intrinsic Value
320.34 USD
Overvaluation 43%
Intrinsic Value
Price
Worst Case
Base Case
Best Case

Valuation History
Caseys General Stores Inc

What is Valuation History?
Ask AI Assistant
What other research platforms think about CASY?

Let our AI compare Alpha Spread’s intrinsic value with external valuations from Simply Wall St, GuruFocus, ValueInvesting.io, Seeking Alpha, and others.

Discover External Valuations
Why is CASY valued this way?

Let our AI break down the key assumptions behind the intrinsic value calculation for Caseys General Stores Inc.

Explain Valuation
Compare CASY to

Fundamental Analysis

Company Overview
Loading...
Business Segments
Loading...
Economic Moat
Loading...
Earnings Call
Loading...
Management
Loading...
Contacts
Loading...
Bear Theses

An overreliance on volatile fuel margins could squeeze profitability if oil prices spike or if aggressive competitors employ fuel price discounting, limiting Casey’s ability to offset rising operational costs.

Casey’s concentrated footprint in smaller Midwestern towns creates subdued growth opportunities and exposes the company to demographic headwinds, such as declining rural populations or reduced discretionary spending in those regions.

Expanding freshly prepared food offerings, particularly the signature pizza program, increases complexity in supply chain logistics and labor requirements, potentially eroding margins if execution falters or ingredient costs surge.

Bull Theses

Continued growth in Casey’s high-margin prepared food business—especially its well-regarded pizza program—supports strong same-store sales expansion and differentiates the chain from convenience-store peers.

Strong brand recognition and customer loyalty in core rural and small-town markets grants Casey’s an enduring competitive edge, enabling higher in-store traffic and helping maintain stable operating margins.

Ongoing improvements in digital ordering and a robust rewards program have the potential to elevate average ticket size, drive customer frequency, and open new cross-selling opportunities, bolstering long-term revenue growth.

Show More Less
How do you feel about CASY?
Bearish
Neutral
Bullish
Financials
Annual
Quarterly
TTM
Annual
Quarterly
TTM

Balance Sheet Decomposition
Caseys General Stores Inc

Current Assets 1.2B
Cash & Short-Term Investments 458.1m
Receivables 195.5m
Other Current Assets 523.6m
Non-Current Assets 7.2B
PP&E 5.8B
Intangibles 1.2B
Other Non-Current Assets 118.6m
Current Liabilities 1.1B
Accounts Payable 673.9m
Accrued Liabilities 361.3m
Other Current Liabilities 102.8m
Non-Current Liabilities 3.6B
Long-Term Debt 2.4B
Other Non-Current Liabilities 1.2B
Efficiency

Free Cash Flow Analysis
Caseys General Stores Inc

Last Value
3-Years Average
FCF Margin
Conversion Rate

Earnings Waterfall
Caseys General Stores Inc

Revenue
16.4B USD
Cost of Revenue
-12.5B USD
Gross Profit
3.9B USD
Operating Expenses
-3.1B USD
Operating Income
850.3m USD
Other Expenses
-268.7m USD
Net Income
581.7m USD
Fundamental Scores

CASY Profitability Score
Profitability Due Diligence

Caseys General Stores Inc's profitability score is 50/100. The higher the profitability score, the more profitable the company is.

Positive 3Y Average ROE
Positive ROE
Healthy Gross Margin
Sustainable 3Y Average Gross Margin
50/100
Profitability
Score

Caseys General Stores Inc's profitability score is 50/100. The higher the profitability score, the more profitable the company is.

CASY Solvency Score
Solvency Due Diligence

Caseys General Stores Inc's solvency score is 57/100. The higher the solvency score, the more solvent the company is.

High Altman Z-Score
Low D/E
Long-Term Solvency
Short-Term Solvency
57/100
Solvency
Score

Caseys General Stores Inc's solvency score is 57/100. The higher the solvency score, the more solvent the company is.

Wall St
Price Targets

CASY Price Targets Summary
Caseys General Stores Inc

Wall Street analysts forecast CASY stock price to rise over the next 12 months.

According to Wall Street analysts, the average 1-year price target for CASY is 585.84 USD with a low forecast of 469.9 USD and a high forecast of 735 USD.

Lowest
Price Target
469.9 USD
17% Downside
Average
Price Target
585.84 USD
4% Upside
Highest
Price Target
735 USD
31% Upside
View Analyst Estimates
View Analyst Estimates

Dividends

Dividend Yield
Lowest
Average
Highest
Dividend Per Share
N/A
Growth 3Y
Growth 5Y
Growth 10Y
Dividend Safety Score
Very
Unsafe
Unsafe
Safe
Very
Safe
0
25
50
75
100
Shareholder Yield

Current shareholder yield for CASY is .

Shareholder yield represents the total return a company provides to its shareholders, calculated as the sum of dividend yield, buyback yield, and debt paydown yield. What is shareholder yield?

Shareholder Yield
Dividend Yield
Lowest
Average
Highest
Buyback Yield
Lowest
Average
Highest
Debt Paydown Yield
Lowest
Average
Highest

Competitive Landscape

Company Market Cap Intrinsic Valuation Profitability Solvency Price Change
1Y 3Y 5Y

Ownership

CASY Insider Trading
Buy and sell transactions by insiders

CASY News

Other Videos
What is the Intrinsic Value of one CASY stock?

The intrinsic value of one CASY stock under the Base Case scenario is 320.34 USD.

Is CASY stock undervalued or overvalued?

Compared to the current market price of 563.15 USD, Caseys General Stores Inc is Overvalued by 43%.

Back to Top