` Comparison: CLMT, VLO - Alpha Spread

CLMT
vs
VLO

Over the past 12 months, CLMT has significantly outperformed VLO, delivering a return of +12% compared to the VLO's 10% drop.

Smart Verdict
AI-Powered

Not Sure Which Stock Wins?
Let AI Decide.
CLMT
VLO
One-click summary across all key metrics.
Ranked results with clear takeaways.
No spreadsheets, no guesswork.
One-click summary across all key metrics.
Ranked results with clear takeaways.
No spreadsheets, no guesswork.
Start AI Comparison
Valuation
Growth
Profitability
Solvency
Comparing Valuation
Running a multi-layered valuation analysis to compare how attractive each stock is.
Comparing Growth
Financial growth, forecasts, volatility, and historical drawdowns.
Comparing Profitability
Margins, returns on capital, and the consistency of profitability.
Comparing Solvency
Debt levels, liquidity, interest coverage, and bankruptcy risk.
Summarizing...
We need a little more time to summarize the results

Valuation Comparison

CLMT Intrinsic Value
24.958 USD
Undervaluation 39%
Intrinsic Value
Price
VLO Intrinsic Value
192.3 USD
Undervaluation 30%
Intrinsic Value
Price
Company Last Price Intrinsic Value DCF Value Relative Value Wall St Target
Calumet Specialty Products Partners LP
NASDAQ:CLMT
15.335 USD
Valero Energy Corp
NYSE:VLO
134.48 USD
Valuation Scenario:
Bear Case
Base Case
Bull Case

Growth Comparison

Growth Over Time
CLMT, VLO

CLMT
VLO
Add Stock
Revenue
www.alphaspread.com
Company LTM Historical Growth Growth Streak % Positive Years Max Drawdown Volatility Forecasted Growth
3 Years 5 Years 10 Years 1 Year 3 Years
Calumet Specialty Products Partners LP
Revenue
Valero Energy Corp
Revenue

All metrics are calculated based on data from the last 10 years.

Profitability Comparison

Free Cash Flow
CLMT, VLO

CLMT
VLO
Add Stock
Free Cash Flow
www.alphaspread.com
Company LTM Average Historical Growth FCF Margin Conversion
3 Years 5 Years 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years
Calumet Specialty Products Partners LP
NASDAQ:CLMT
Valero Energy Corp
NYSE:VLO
What is Free Cash Flow?

Gross Margin

CLMT
2.9%
VLO
2.5%

Operating Margin

CLMT
-1.9%
VLO
1.7%

Net Margin

CLMT
-7.4%
VLO
0.6%

FCF Margin

CLMT
-2.7%
VLO
2.7%

ROE

CLMT
55.2%
VLO
3.1%

ROA

CLMT
-13.8%
VLO
1.2%

ROIC

CLMT
-4.2%
VLO
4.3%

ROCE

CLMT
-5.2%
VLO
4.6%

Solvency Comparison

Balance Sheet Comparison

Stocks Performance

Stocks Performance
CLMT, VLO

Loading

Performance Gap
CLMT, VLO

Loading
CLMT
VLO
Difference
www.alphaspread.com

Performance By Year
CLMT, VLO

Loading
CLMT
VLO
Add Stock
Not Sure Which Stock Wins?
Let AI Decide
One-click summary across all key metrics.
Ranked results with clear takeaways.
No spreadsheets, no guesswork.
Start AI Comparison
Compare CLMT to other stocks
Unlock Full Access to Alpha Spread
Create Free Account