Badger Infrastructure Solutions Ltd
TSX:BDGI
Earnings Call Analysis
Q4-2023 Analysis
Badger Infrastructure Solutions Ltd
Safety initiatives at Badger Infrastructure Solutions have become more than just regulations; they define the company's culture. The 2023 campaign 'Making Safety Personal' has led to both a safer workplace and improved economic performance. Safety is not just a moral obligation but also a competitive advantage.
Badger has delivered outstanding financial results, with annual revenues skyrocketing to $683.8 million, a growth rate of 20%. This remarkable achievement owes to a strategic overhaul begun in 2022 and ongoing optimization efforts throughout 2023. With the deployment of a new pricing engine mid-year, the company witnessed its adjusted EBITDA soar by an impressive 50%, double the pace of revenue growth, elevating margins to 22%— a summit reached for the first time in three years. Earnings per share followed suit, climbing by 128% to reach $1.21 in contrast to the previous $0.53— a clear sign of flourishing prosperity.
The company's operational footprint has expanded, with the Red Deer manufacturing plant producing 217 hydrovacs in the current year, a leap from the prior year's 112 units. This scaling, along with the retirement of older units and the refurbishment of additional ones, has grown the fleet size by 11%. Furthermore, a refined focus on fleet utilization and pricing has pushed the revenue per truck (RPT) to over $43,500 per month, marking nearly a 10% increase from the prior year.
In recognition of its financial success and with a future focus, the Board of Directors has endorsed a 4.3% hike in quarterly cash dividends, uplifting shareholder returns. Meanwhile, Badger sets its sights on 2024, envisioning the manufacturing of up to 220 hydrovacs, 45 refurbishments, and expecting a fleet growth of 7% to 10%, with a calculated capital expenditure of $90 million to $130 million.
The final stretch of 2023 bolstered Badger's earnings once more, with a 16% surge in quarterly revenue, chiefly propelled by a robust 20% increase in U.S operations. Despite a marginal downturn in Canadian revenues due to reduced partner activities and static corporate earnings, the company enjoyed a rise in gross profit and EBITDA margins, a direct outcome of effective pricing tactics and expanded operational capacities.
Badger's financial structure remains resilient and versatile, providing a solid foundation for continued organic and strategic growth. The company's leverage has improved, with a debt-to-EBITDA ratio decreasing to 1.3x, underscoring a sound balance sheet. Its receivables portfolio is fortified, predominantly composed of investment-grade clients and exhibiting efficient collection timelines.
The management at Badger takes pride in their strategic efforts paying off, staying optimistic about future endeavors based on promising early performances in the year. The company envisions sustained growth within the excavation services sector across North America. Additionally, Badger invites stakeholders to engage further through its upcoming Investor Day, facilitating deeper insights into its strategic vision and operations.
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Good day, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Badger Infrastructure Solutions 2023 Fourth Quarter and Annual Earnings Results Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Lisa Olarte, Director of Investor Relations and Financial Planning. Please go ahead.
Good morning, everyone. Welcome to our fourth quarter and annual 2023 earnings call. My name is Lisa Olarte, Badger's Director of Investor Relations and Financial Planning.
Joining me on the call this morning are Badger's President and CEO, Rob Blackadar; and our CFO, Rob Dawson. Badger's 2024 4th quarter and annual earnings release, MD&A, AIF and financial statements were released after market closed yesterday and are available on the Investors section of Badger's website and on SEDAR+. We are required to note that some of the statements made today may contain forward-looking information. In fact, all statements made today, which are not statements of historical facts are considered to be forward-looking statements. We make these forward-looking statements based on certain assumptions that we consider to be reasonable. However, forward-looking statements are always subject to certain risks and uncertainties, and undue reliance should not be placed on them as actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied. For more information about material assumptions, risks and uncertainties that may be relevant to such forward-looking statements, please refer to Badger's 2023 MD&A, along with the 2023 AIF. I will now turn the call over to Rob Blackadar.
Thanks, Lisa, and good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining our 2023 4th quarter and full year earnings call. Before we get into the results, I'd like to take a moment to talk about safety. In 2023, Badger had strong safety results tied to the entire team's focus on our Making Safety Personal campaign for all of last year. Great companies are safe companies, and there is a strong correlation between safety and economic performance. This is a testament to the team's commitment to safety and our investments in the right tools to help our people be successful every day.
Now on to our annual results. The team finished the year strong with record annual revenues, gross profits and adjusted EBITDA. Our top line annual revenue of $683.8 million, grew by 20%, driven by our commercial strategy launched at the beginning of 2022 and our continued focus on utilization throughout 2023. Importantly, we also continue to see the growth in adjusted EBITDA, up 50% year-over-year, 2.5x the growth in revenue. The launch of our new pricing engine in the middle of 2023 also contributed to these improved margins. Our annual adjusted EBITDA margin was 22%, up from 17.5% in 2022, the highest we have achieved in 3 years. Our earnings per share was up 128% at $1.21 per share compared with $0.53 per share in 2022. The Red Deer manufacturing plant delivered 217 hydrovacs this year versus 112 hydrovac units in 2022. We also retired 79 units and refurbished 19, ending the year with 1,534 units and growing our fleet by 11%.
We achieved RPT, or revenue per truck, per month north of $43,500 in 2023, up almost 10% from the previous year due to Badger's continued focus on fleet utilization and pricing. As we look ahead to 2024, our fleet plan includes manufacturing between 190 to 220 hydrovacs, refurbishing between 35 to 45 hydrovacs and retiring between 70 to 90 units. This allows us to grow our fleet by 7% to 10% and spend between $90 million to $130 million in capital. Included in this capital range is our hydrovac production, our refurbishments, ancillary equipment purchases and other capital projects.
On another note, the Board of Directors has approved a 4.3% increase to the quarterly cash dividend to CAD 0.18 per common share. This will be effective for the first quarter of 2024 with payment to be made on or about April 15, 2024, to all shareholders of record at the close of business on March 31, 2024. I'll now turn the call over to Rob Dawson to discuss our Q4 financial results in more detail.
Thank you, Rob. As you saw in our fourth quarter release, our team delivered another strong quarter of results. We had record fourth quarter revenue, up 16% from last year, driven by our U.S. operations, which were up 20%. Our Canadian operations revenue fell marginally in the fourth quarter due to lower activity from our operating partners and relatively flat revenue from our corporate operations. Gross profit and adjusted EBITDA margins continued to rise in the fourth quarter, reflecting the operating leverage gain from our pricing strategies and the scalability of our branch footprint and support functions. The trend in our adjusted EBITDA margins continue to improve at 19.9% compared with 18.8% in the fourth quarter of 2022. In aggregate, there were 3 discrete nonroutine items totaling $5.7 million that impacted fourth quarter 2023 adjusted EBITDA. First, Badger conducted a detailed assessment of its inventory on hand at its manufacturing facility as part of the first year under a comprehensive new inventory management system. This resulted in a $2.7 million write-down of the aged manufacturing inventory. Second, we had an accrual of $900,000 related to unresolved tax audits. And lastly, as a result of our strong full year 2023 performance, we recorded an increase of $2.1 million to our full year bonus accrual. Q4 earnings per share was $0.14 per share, an increase of 17% over the prior year.
Now on to the balance sheet. Our capital allocation priorities remain unchanged. We continue to have a strong, flexible balance sheet to support our organic growth and commercial strategies. Our compliance leverage ended the year at 1.3x debt to EBITDA, down from 1.6x a year ago. Our receivables portfolio remains strong with over 90% of our customers having investment-grade characteristics, and 90% of our receivables were below 90 days outstanding. I will now turn things back over to Rob Blackadar for some final comments.
Thanks, Rob. So before we open up for questions, a few last comments. We are pleased to see our strategies of driving strong utilization, commercial sales and now pricing starting to pay off in our results. Badger's long-term growth prospects remain unchanged, and we are encouraged by early indications from our January and February performance so far this year. We continue to believe Badger is uniquely positioned to capitalize on the significant opportunity for nondestructive excavation services in key end markets in both the U.S. and Canada.
Finally, I want to remind everyone that we are hosting an Investor Day on March 20 in Toronto. To get more information and to register, please visit our Investor Relations page at ir.badgerinc.com. We look forward to hosting many of you on March 20. So with those comments, let's turn it back to the operator for questions. Operator?
[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Krista Friesen with CIBC.
I guess I just wanted to ask, can you give us a little bit more detail of what you're seeing in the U.S. market right now? I maybe would have thought that RPT growth in the U.S. may have been a bit stronger, just given the pricing initiative and the strength in the U.S. right now. So if you can maybe just elaborate on what you're seeing, that would be great.
Yes, Krista. So we continue to see strong end markets and solid demand in the U.S. with a lot of various projects that both we're on now and then what we have in the queue coming up for Q1 -- for the remainder of Q1 and Q2 and the rest of the year. The markets themselves are very, very strong. We work with a lot of different economists from various organizations and forecasters in the both construction and industrial markets, and they're sharing the same thing for the United States. Regarding RPT, as the year goes on, obviously, we still have seasonality in the business. We've referenced the last few years about raising the shoulder seasons and et cetera. But while we're always going to be in seasonal markets, we will have certain seasonality even if we raise the numbers on that. And so RPT will decline typically in our fourth quarter because it's one of our slower quarters and obviously picks up into the spring and summer months. Overall, though, on RPT, you have to keep in mind too that it's an amalgamation of 3 things. It's our utilization, it's our pricing, but also it's the truck volume. And we continue to add trucks. So as we add additional trucks into the fleet and grow the business and grow the fleet, RPT -- that's going to affect RPT. So those are some of the kind of the color that we look at when we think about RPT, Krista. Anything you want to add, Rob?
Yes, I would just echo what Rob said. I'd focus on the annualized or the trailing 4 quarters, whichever you want to think about it, RPT, and we added 11% to our truck fleet and 20% to revenue. So you can see, I think, on an annual basis, the very positive impact of our focus on both pricing and utilization.
Okay. Great. And then maybe just on your fleet plan for this year. Can you just talk about your thought process as you think about how much you want to grow the fleet by even something as simple as, last year you talked about refurbishing 50 trucks, and this year, I think you're guiding to 35 to 45 and just why you maybe didn't take it up to that 50 number?
Yes. So on the refurbishment, we started off the program, and we had identified some trucks that we felt were going to be coming due and would be good candidates for the refurbishment as well as when we launched, and I think I shared this in the last Q, whenever we did this call. We ended up having to evolve our strategy. We had taken our refurbishment program out to multiple different shops that could help us with the refurbishment and give us an honor of warranty. We realized that not all shops are created equal. So we took down the guidance on refurbishments for the end of -- or I guess, for Q4 and the full year last year.
For this year, we wanted to ramp up in kind of an orderly way and not have another misfire like that, Krista. So that's why you see the range where you see it. As we see opportunities, obviously, we're going to take advantage of it, but we feel comfortable with those numbers. We just don't want to overcommit because like you suggested, kind of start off high and then we realized, you know what, as we're launching this program, we were -- kind of the evolution of the program, we were maybe a little bit more -- a little bit too ambitious on that program. So we feel comfortable with these numbers. I feel comfortable, though, as well as both with any of our manufacturing or refurbishment, as we have more and more demand in the company and the business can support it, and we feel comfortable with our end markets. We can be on the higher end of that range or if we need to just -- we're always evaluating where we need to be, either on the range or if we need to go higher. So we just have a lot of flexibility to be able to do that.
Our next question comes from Yuri Lynk with Canaccord Genuity.
Maybe just talk a little bit about how your price increases are being accepted in the market? And any color on how your competitors are reacting, if at all?
Yes. So the model that we built is that of kind of a dynamic, getting away from more static pricing in some of our end markets and going to dynamic pricing. And so far, we've done that in a very orderly way rather than trying to step change, maybe kind of changes in pricing really too quickly or too dramatically or drastically. We've done it kind of in a step change type way. But our pricing really is predicated on, I just think of kind of basics of what the location or the branches' utilization is as well as the demand in that market, competitors or market position. We have a handful of things that we use to decide the pricing and that's all actually inputted into a pricing engine that we built called CPQ or configure price quote.
So far, we've had good reception on it. We've been very close to our customers. Our customers know that the last few years with really strong inflation and especially in '21, '22, when inflation was going up pretty dramatically, Badger didn't follow suit at the same rate as inflation. And so if anything, we're slightly behind that rate of inflation and so us being able to pass through some reasonable pricing and improvements and increases have been fairly well received. Just like with everyone on this call and everyone in the room I'm in, no one likes a price increase, but it's also, it's part of our business and without us being able to get pricing, it just -- it doesn't allow us to grow and really drive results. As far as our competitors and what we're seeing regarding their pricing, it's our belief that many of our more regional or local players and competitors in our industry and our markets, they have a desire as well to raise pricing, and we've actually seen them follow suit with us in many of our markets. We haven't had a single market that I'm aware of, and I don't believe we actually have 1, whereas we've taken up pricing, our competitors are going the other way. Because of our size and scale, we're able to really leverage a lot of our cost and our purchasing power and the ability to drive good margins and our competitors, they just don't -- they're not able to buy trucks and operate at the local level necessarily as efficiently as we are. So I think, just logically, they want to follow suit with us, and it helps them as well. So hopefully, that gives you enough color there, Yuri.
Yes. I'm not surprised to hear that. I mean, correct me if I'm wrong, but all the alternatives to nondestructive excavation, the cost of that's also gone up, right? Like you're not that aligned with the market.
No. So obviously, a lot of the folks on the line have followed Badger for many, many years, including yourself, but the cost of the trucks and not just Badger's cost, but you can look at the cost of our competitors who manufacture trucks, manufacturing competitors, they -- all of their costs have gone up, all of the chassis costs have gone up and obviously, that puts pressure on any kind of -- our competitors, and it also has put pressure on us to have us address our pricing. So we're all kind of in the same boat, and we operate in the same markets. So that's why you're seeing -- we just haven't lost -- I'm not aware of any deals that we've lost tied to pricing. I know there's a few, I've talked about a few internally here, but not many at this point. But again, we're being very reasonable. We're not trying to step change and ask 20% pricing or anything like that because that's just not realistic because at that point, I think we would start driving customers away.
Okay. Last one for me, a quick one. No mention of your kind of 3- to 5-year 28%, 29% EBITDA margin target. Just give us an update on that aspirational goal.
Yes. So we're still marching on toward those original goals that we set out at Investor Day in September of 2022 and if you think about '22, I think we ended the year at 17.5% adjusted EBITDA. This year, for '23, we ended at 22%, and we're marching toward those goals, Yuri. Rob and I were chatting about -- Rob Dawson and I were chatting about this, I think about 2 weeks ago, and we feel like we're actually ahead of our plan slightly on marching toward that. But just keep in mind here, in just under 3 weeks, we're going to be having an Investor Day, and Rob and I are planning on kind of doing a little bit of a refresh on the whole long range planning and how we present it. And I think you'll appreciate what you see.
Our next question comes from Michael Doumet with Scotiabank.
I'll start off with, I guess, a relatively simple one. Just thinking of the write-down on the inventory is pretty self-explanatory, but I just wanted to get some background on the $2.1 million true-up in the short-term comp and whether that was included in the gross margin? Just trying to get a better sense for how the gross margins trended in the quarter.
Michael, it's Rob Dawson here. The annual bonus salaried employees, there's a number of them that are included both in the costs related that go down to our gross margin as well as into the cost and G&A. So it's spread in both of those places. I don't have the split of between those 2 places, but it is true.
Okay. And that's effectively just a catch-up of what was potentially a lower estimate for that cost through the year?
That's correct. And we'll be adjusting the way we do accrual bonus going forward, but we left that at target for the first 3 quarters of the year and then true it up for the full year to actual in the fourth quarter.
That's helpful. Bigger picture question here. Just on the retirements and the refurbs. Together, it looks like, if you combine those 2 at the midpoint for 2024, it looks like 120 trucks. So I guess, the first question, is it fair to assume that, that's kind of the run rate that you'd like to do going forward, to just smooth out production? And then the second question, that 120 in terms of retirements and refurbs, that represents about 8% of the fleet and effectively implies an economic life of 12.5 years per truck. So I'm just thinking -- and I've asked this question before in prior calls, but should we be more permanently adjusting our view of the economic life of the truck at this point?
Why don't you take the first part, Rob, and then I'll take the second.
Yes. You're exactly right, Michael. When you think about the life of our truck, we've always said, about 10 years and then would be looking to retire those trucks. Obviously, over 1,500 units in the fleet, the actual performance and then wear on those trucks is quite -- it's definitely not homogenous. It's quite heterogeneous. And so some are earlier and quite a few are later. Over the last several years, though, one, we've done a very thorough review of our fleet with our fleet operations. And with the higher percentage of our revenue and majority of our growth or a lot of our growth coming from the more southern parts of our geographic footprint, the wear in those vehicles is quite a bit less than it has been historically, even when you're not even on road, in a lot of oilfield and off-road environments like you would have been in the earlier days when it was more of an oilfield service business.
So that's the first thing that's helped these trucks. It's also far less caustic environment because less salt on the roads and all those sorts of things, too. So the chassis are wearing a lot better than they used to be. So we are seeing, on average, possibly the age of those trucks -- we're not in a position today to say definitively, it's going to be a 12 or a 13-year life for those trucks. We're continuing to depreciate them at 10 years. But for sure, the average life of our units based on a detailed review of the wear and tear on them as we've moved into this refurbishment program shows that there's more life in these trucks than perhaps there was in the past.
The other thing -- and that's more of a structural change. The other one that is more of a onetime is, during COVID, utilization was very low. And so the trucks, we get an extra year or 2 a life of them, just from the nature of them not being as hardly driven during that period. So you're seeing a small dividend or a small sort of holiday as a result of that. But going forward, and this is the way we've been talking about it with everybody, we do see the ability to manage our both retirements and refurbishments such that we can build at the manufacturing facility a relatively stable number of trucks and add in that 7% to 10% range to our fleet on an annual basis.
Obviously, very good from a capital spending and planning standpoint and more importantly, very good for the efficient operation of a manufacturing operation.
I'm going to add one quick thing too, Michael, that might give you more color as well. Last couple of quarters, we've obviously been talking about the refurbishment program. And I've kind of intimated to, on these calls actually, that around the 10-year mark, the company has exit vehicles, and it probably looks like that externally. But I've had a chance to actually visit with several longer-term fleet leaders within the business since having those calls and saying that on these calls. And actually, historically, the company has evaluated every single truck and it just -- it looks like when you think about our retirement cycles and the way we report them quarterly and annually, that it all happens around the 10-year mark but actually, every single truck has been -- being evaluated for quite some time in Badger's history. And where it makes sense is, where we engage on the retirement cycle.
As Rob suggested, a lot of our business started in Canada and has actually moved through the northern states, and now we're really across both all of Canada, Northern states and now the Southern states in a big way and we're realizing that the Southern State trucks have a lot more life in them. And even our chassis manufacturers have said the same thing to them as far as the ability to do those refurbs and they're good candidates for that. So we're still doing the same thing we have as a company in our history of evaluating every truck and is it ready to retire or not. I think it's a little early to start changing models in a big way to say, okay, now we're moving from 10 years to 12.5 because remember, we just started a refurbishment program, I believe, Q1, Q2 of last year, just getting it started. So -- but more to come on that, and you'll hear more about that at that Investor Day as well, Michael.
[Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from John Gibson with BMO Capital Markets.
I just had one, obviously, nice to see the new build program and CapEx outlook. There's quite a wide range of capital spending for 2024 I guess and I'm wondering, how do you think about the cadence of build? Are you kind of in a wait and see until the back half of the year? Or do you expect that, that build program to be relatively consistent quarter-over-quarter?
Yes. So it's relatively consistent quarter-over-quarter. And I can't remember, I think it was actually Q4 of 2022, we started giving a little bit of build guidance which we've never really given before, and we're largely in line with that. With the caveat at the time, we weren't doing refurbishments, now we are. So you can just kind of factor that in and it ties out on that. And if you want more color on that, I'm not sure if you heard that this, again, I think, 4, 5 quarters ago, you can call us after the call, and we can give you what we said on that call instead of having to go find what we did, but we're largely in line with that. We're not like trying to massage or we're not in any kind of wait and see. Our end markets today are strong and we have very solid demand. And as we've been adding in the additional trucks, we've also been able to hold and, in many cases, drive utilization in some of these end markets. So as long as the demand is there, the return profiles are there and we can make good returns, we're going to keep feeding it. And we're doing this all the while, while keeping our balance sheet really, really strong.
In fact, I look at where our balance sheet is today. And Rob and I, again, talking about it a few days ago, we're very pleased with how we've been able to factor in the growth and keep the balance sheet as solid as it is. Anything you want to add on that, Rob?
I would just add, when we're looking in year at managing the fleet, it's all 3 levers. You have manufacturing, retirements and refurbs. And I'd really -- we're focusing on how is revenue looking and trying to be as flexible as we can with the fleet to make sure that there's enough capacity to meet market demand. And so last year, we grew the fleet by 11%, but we did end the year with 217 units produced, which is great for the consistency in the per unit cost at a manufacturing plant. And we held back a little bit on some retirements and some refurbs which allowed us to grow that fleet a little bit so we could have enough trucks to deliver at 20% revenue growth. That's the way we're managing this going forward. I'd like people to start focusing on that 7% to 10% range of fleet growth on an annualized basis. And we start at the mid-range for manufacturing or whatever we may start the year at, and there is some flexibility in year to either dial it back a little bit or more importantly, to ramp it up in the latter part of the year if we see some real busy demand coming in through the summer and the peak months into the early fall.
Yes. And for us, John, I'll probably add like -- we're being found in the question and answer, back and forth between me and Rob, but I'd probably add one additional caveat is, we're trying to grow the company in as orderly way as we can. We have good end markets and good strong demand, but we are trying to hold utilization. And like I said earlier, many of our end markets were driving good utilization, like it's increasing at a good clip. We're feathering in new trucks, and we're working on our pricing all at the same time. And so as you can imagine, you really need to do that in an orderly way rather than just build a bunch of trucks, drive a bunch of revenue for the short term. That, to us, doesn't feel very foundational. That feels very much like a blip on a radar, and we really want to be more foundational growth. And we talk about that a lot internally amongst the management team. And that's kind of our philosophy, if that helps you, John, with how we're thinking about things.
Yes, that's really helpful. I guess, what I'm trying to get is, what would be the delta causing you to go from either the low end to the high end of that capital spending range? Is it more just the flexibility in that build program or are there other issues at play?
It's literally the simple math of the low and high points of the 2 of the 3 things that incur capital costs refurbishments and truck builds.
Our next question comes from Frederic Bastien with Raymond James.
I was wondering if you could talk about the geographies in the U.S. that are -- where you're seeing the best revenue growth and sales penetration.
Yes. Thanks, Frederic. So our -- what we're seeing in the U.S., some of our end markets, we're seeing it really across almost every one of the larger major markets. We're seeing good demand and a lot of end market projects, both uber large projects as well as regional and smaller local servicing that we do with our trucks. But it's really across the board. In the United States, there's good demand. That's why you're seeing some of the other big equipment manufacturers and the big rental houses, they're all having really strong demand as well. We all operate in the same markets and in many cases, the same customers.
For us, we've been fortunate enough, Frederic, to start at the -- I think it was in April of 2022, a national accounts program that supports some of the largest contractors in North America that work all across U.S. and all across Canada, and that has also helped to shore up our business. And we had this concept of lifting the shoulders and it really is helping to drive demand more year-round. We still have seasonality because we're in seasonal markets, but it is driving the demand more year-round than we have historically. Those customers, the national account customers, in many cases, continue to have record backlogs. And some of those customers are public, you can go, you can search them and find out about their backlog and their book of business, and some of them are private but they have record backlogs, and they are actually limited by finding qualified people to run their projects.
But we stand with all of our customers, whether big or small, local, regional or national, but we stand with them all to support them. And I think that's what's -- what we're -- what we've -- how we've been able to have so much success the last few years on our revenue growth.
The last thing I'll share is, you can go across almost any kind of trend project happening in the U.S. So think of like the concept of the industrial plants that are upgrading and top-grading, data centers and steel mills and any kind of power plants. Anything that is infrastructure related that the government in the U.S. has really started pushing money toward, Badger has been a beneficiary of, and those markets are really strong. The only thing that we've seen, there's a bit of a shift and it's happening mainly in the U.S., and it's a slight shift, is on some of the battery electric vehicle plants. Those feel like they're starting to slow down the rate of future projects. They're not canceling -- with 1 exception, they're not canceling a bunch of projects. They're just not, the rate of growth of additional new ones. But other than that, the rest of the end markets are pretty strong.
Thanks for unpacking all of it. Now based on your -- I guess, your outlook, is it reasonable to expect the revenue growth in 2024 to look similar to what you experienced in 2023?
We don't give revenue guidance, but the -- like I was just sharing, solid demand in the markets, but we don't give revenue growth. Rob, I don't know if you want to approach that, how we could answer that.
We've got 5-year revenue growth guidance in the market that we provided at our 2022 Investor Day with 21% as a base, 5-year at 15%. First year, we delivered 25%, second year which is 2023, it was 20%. So at some point, I think you're going to start to see a teenager or something to bring that average in a little bit. We'll be refreshing our views on that at our Investor Day. But as Rob said, we're not going to be providing specific point guidance for next year. We do also look at our truck growth in that 7% to 10% range and note that last year was 11% as well.
Appreciate that. But are you still comfortable with that 15% 5-year target? Is that right?
As an overall range, yes, we haven't changed that. And like I shared earlier, we're probably slightly ahead of that at this moment in time. But in less than 3 weeks, we're going to be doing our Investor Day, and I think you'll get a little bit more color along those lines.
Our next question comes from Trevor Reynolds with Acumen Capital.
Just wanted to touch on the refurbishments quickly again. Have those costs been coming in, in line with your expectations so far?
Actually, they have been really, really -- the suppliers that we've found have done a really good job of keeping the cost right on what we've been talking about all along. But there's one other caveat to that, Trevor, that may give you more color as well. Not only are the costs coming in line, which is obviously important to make sure we're driving the returns and our returns definitely improved over 2023. But in addition to that, the trucks that are coming out as a result of the cost investment that we're putting into them, they've been very well received by the field. And every one of the trucks that we've actually delivered back into the field is out driving revenue right now. So obviously, the return profile on that, on those trucks, is really, really strong and helps to drive the whole ROIC for the whole company. So it's good stuff.
That's great. That answered the second question. But just touching on the -- like you dialed back a little bit, I think, in terms of what your expectations were. Maybe just the pace of refurbishments in 2024. Is that -- your guidance, is that kind of a flat level through the year? Or is that a front-end loaded number? Like if you are able to find additional partners, do you expect that number to potentially go higher?
Well, there's a lot of people who can do the work, but they move at a different pace. It's not the lack of people who can actually change out an engine, a transmission, a transfer case and a blower. It's actually just their capabilities to do it in an expeditious way. And for us, we've found a couple of partners that can do the volume to support the guidance we gave. It is potential that we could ramp that up. But keep in mind, the other caveat to the refurbishment program is not just the work being done, even though that's what we're just talking about, but it's also having candidate trucks to feed the pipeline to have them refurbed. And if a truck is running and performing, we're not going to just put it through a refurb automatically, if it's actually doing just fine out in the field.
So we feel comfortable with the guidance we gave. We do -- like I said earlier, we do have the capabilities to ramp it up. But last year, we were a little exuberant when we started the program and now we just want to put out something that we know we can perform to and it isn't too disruptive to the business, and that's what we gave the guidance on.
Thank you. I'm showing no further questions at this time. I would now like to turn it back to Rob Blackadar for closing remarks.
Thank you, operator. So on behalf of all of us at Badger, thanks to our customers, our employees, suppliers and shareholders for your ongoing support that drives Badger's success. Operator, you may now end the call. Thank you.
This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.