Docebo Inc
TSX:DCBO
Earnings Call Analysis
Q4-2023 Analysis
Docebo Inc
Docebo, a company focused on enterprise customers, has demonstrated a successful profitable growth strategy, highlighted by a 28% increase in subscription revenue and total revenue growth of 27% in Q4. This impressive growth has been accompanied by a robust free cash flow margin of 14.2% and an adjusted EBITDA margin that well exceeded guidance at 13.2%. Building on this momentum, Docebo has completed strategic tuck-in acquisitions, including PeerBoard and Edugo, which bring AI technology and expertise to the fold. These advancements will be visible in the market later this year.
Docebo's leadership has seen changes, with the transition of a key executive to Chief Innovation Officer focusing on leveraging novel trends in Learning & Development (L&D). This emphasis on innovation aims to ensure the company remains at the forefront of the industry.
The company's Q4 performance was solid, with substantial subscription revenue growth of 28%. The enterprise segment showed improved execution, and Docebo's ability to penetrate mid to large organizations with complex needs remains strong. Geographically, there's an observed positive trend in Europe, while North America continues to showcase resilience. Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) grew 24% to $194.3 million, and the company saw significant enterprise deals and a notable customer win with a major US bank.
Docebo secured several major enterprise wins, including with top industry players such as the Special Olympics International and prominent brands like Valentino and Pirelli. Expansion within existing accounts like Stanley Black & Decker and a Big 5 US-based technology company highlights the platform's growing footprint. The company is also increasingly optimistic about entering the government sector and is on track to secure FedRAMP certification.
Docebo is set to unveil new AI capabilities, including an enhanced Docebo Shape with a chatbot interface, as well as a new virtual role-play technology aimed at sales enablement, among other uses. These products will be launched in late Q3 2024 following early access in April. The company's five pillars of growth focus on dominating external use cases, expanding enterprise customer base, tapping into the government sector, strengthening strategic partnerships, and driving upsell and cross-sell efforts.
Docebo's subscription revenues reached $46.5 million, constituting 94% of total Q4 revenue, showing a growth of 28%. The company's total customer count increased by 11% to 3,759, while the average contract value grew by 12% year-over-year. Future priorities include growth with a balanced approach to profitability, continued investment in AI, expansion of go-to-market teams, and achieving FedRAMP compliance. For Q1 2024, Docebo projects revenue between $51 million to $51.3 million, an adjusted EBITDA margin of 12.5% to 13.5%, and overall fiscal year 2024 EBITDA margins of approximately 15%.
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Docebo Q4 2023 Earnings Call. [Operator Instructions]I'd now like to turn the call over to Docebo's Vice President of Investor Relations, Mike McCarthy. Please go ahead, Mike.
Thank you, operator. Before we begin, Docebo would like to remind listeners that certain information discussed today may be forward-looking in nature. Such forward-looking information reflects the company's current views with respect to future events. Any such information is subject to risks, uncertainties and assumptions that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in the forward-looking statements. For more information on risks, uncertainties and assumptions relating to forward-looking statements, please refer to Docebo's public filings, which are available on SEDAR and EDGAR. During the call, we will reference certain non-IFRS financial measures. Although we believe these measures provide useful supplemental information about our financial performance, they are not recognized measures and do not have standardized meanings under IFRS. Please see our MD&A for additional information regarding our non-IFRS financial measures, including reconciliations to the nearest IFRS measure. Please note that unless otherwise stated, all references to any financial figures are in U.S. dollars.Now I'd like to turn the call over to Docebo's CEO, Claudio Erba.
Hello everybody and thank you for joining us for our fourth earnings call. With me today are Alessio Artuffo, our President and COO; and Sukaran Mehta, our CFO. I will begin our call this morning with a short summary of Docebo's success over the past year, Alessio will provide a more detailed overview of Q4 highlights and Sukaran will review our finance performance. Our key growth metrics show the continued improvement as a result of the investments we are making. Docebo is becoming more effective in identifying the needs of enterprise customer and progressing through their organization to close deals. Overall, our profitable growth strategy resulted in a strong subscription revenue growth of 28% in Q4. Additionally, we achieved an adjusted EBITDA margin of 13.2% and a free cash flow margin of 14.2% as we ended the year.I'm also proud to say that during the year we completed 2 important tuck-in acquisitions that brought strategic technology and valuable domain expertise to our product development team, particularly in the field of AI. PeerBoard and Edugo have been successfully integrated within the expected timeline and their contribution to the Docebo platform will start to be visible in the marketplace later this year. This positive financial and operational result enable us to make strategic investments in our future growth and maintain our industry leadership position through innovation. It's from this position of strength that the leadership team and I felt it was the right time for me to transition into the role of Chief Innovation Officer.In my new role, some of the key areas we will focus include: identifying novel ideas and trends in the L&D space and finding ways for Docebo to leverage them; advising Alessio and Fabio the innovation idea for early stage products including product positioning, feature creation and improvement; leading and doing deep research serving as one of the Docebo industry expert [indiscernible] for Docebo positioning as a leader in innovation; and providing ongoing mentorship to the executive leadership team and Board on important technology development and positioning matter. As I pass the baton to Alessio, I'm filled with excitement as I transition into my new position. It's accelerating to think about the future and the incredible possibilities that lies ahead. As Docebo continues to grow and evolve, I am certain that there will be even larger and more exciting achievement waiting to be realized.Now I would like to turn the call over to Alessio.
Thank you, Claudio, and good morning, everyone. As I step into this interim CEO role at Docebo, I would be remiss if I did not mention how fortunate Docebo has been to be led by Claudio and what an honor it is for me to continue to grow the company following his legacy of success. Before discussing the business performance and our improved market position, I would like to briefly share our strategic perspective on the macro trends we saw this quarter. After that, I will go over some of our key performance indicators for the quarter. Macro trends in quarter 4 aligned with our expectations and we expect that 2024 will follow a similar pattern. We expect to see significant enterprise deals that will continue to receive close scrutiny from the C-suite. Our improved execution within the enterprise go-to-market ecosystem is helping us tackle these challenges.Our larger customers who have multiple use cases now view their investment in learning as strategic and mission critical. SMB and first time LMS customers continue to approach their decisions with caution. That said, we continue to penetrate mid to large organizations with complex and multiple use cases leading with a solution that delivers a fast ROI and lend value to our customers. Geographically, we observed a positive trend in Europe indicating a potential improvement in the market. We will continue to monitor this closely as the year progresses. North America, on the other hand, continues to maintain its strong performance showcasing its resilience in the face of broader challenges. Now to the quarter 4 highlights. We're excited to report that subscription revenue increased by 28% and total revenues grew by 27% in quarter 4 with total revenues exceeding the upper end of our guidance range.ARR as of December 31, 2023 of $194.3 million increased 24% or 23% after adjusting for the positive impact of approximately 1 percentage point given the weakening of the U.S. dollar relative to foreign currencies. ARR growth was a result of our improving execution in the enterprise customer segment and our strong appeal across industry verticals. Adjusted EBITDA of 13.2% well exceeded our guidance. Our discipline to drive optimal growth at the right cost has helped us deliver quality growth with operating leverage. Enterprise customers with ACV over $100,000 in ARR accounted for approximately 56% of gross ARR generated in the fourth quarter. Additionally, ACV for new customers in the quarter was about $71,000 compared to $70,500 in the September period. External and average use cases continue to account for more than half of our pipeline.In addition to the progress our enterprise sales team is making, we're steadily increasing our presence with large system integrators. They are helping us access a great number of high quality deals in both enterprise and government segments. Now I would like to highlight a few customer wins, upsells and cross-sells this quarter. We're thrilled to share that Docebo has recently secured a major customer win with one of the Top 4 U.S.-based global banks. This prestigious bank has chosen Docebo to replace their outdated LMS provider in order to meet the onboarding and compliance learning needs of their vast global workforce. This collaboration marks a significant milestone for us as we continue to revolutionize the world of learning and development.Other notable large enterprise wins include Special Olympics International, 3 major Italian brands in the luxury goods and performance automotive industries including Valentino and Pirelli and a leading e-commerce company. Special Olympics International, which serves more than 4 million athletes and unified partners in over 170 countries chose Docebo to address several hybrid use case requirements, including memberships, associations and continued education management. And more exciting news from Europe. We recently partnered with Pirelli to revolutionize partner learning and with Valentino to enhance various external learning initiatives. This includes empowering our customers and partners through education, offering exclusive memberships and providing comprehensive training programs for the retail and franchisee networks.Turning to our amazing customers. We very quickly leveraged our early franchisee and internal use case momentum with Bojangles, having just signed them back in quarter 3. Then there is Stanley Black & Decker, a global leader in tools and outdoor operating manufacturing facilities worldwide. This customer iconic brand include DEWALT, BLACK+DECKER, CRAFTSMAN and STANLEY. During the quarter, the company expanded the scope of their external use case of the Docebo platform being used to support both customer and brand training. And lastly, a Big 5 U.S.-based technology company that we signed in August is expanding the use of Docebo platform. Their partnership supports their multiple use case needs including a large external audience.Now to our government segment. We are increasingly optimistic about our ability to secure a FedRAMP sponsor as well as obtain our FedRAMP certification. Our government sales team is fully staffed and actively selling, establishing relationships that are crucial for Docebo to create a strong pipeline in this important area of growth. Having a clear path to FedRAMP certification, our collaboration with a Big 4 system integrator and our preferred distributor Carahsoft, position us well to succeed in both federal and SLED opportunities. In quarter 4, one of our notable wins came at the state level as the Texas County District and Retirement System chose Docebo for their onboarding and professional development use case needs.Now to OEMs. Performance during the quarter met our expectations. We're excited about the opportunities and progress being made with E&Y and Darwinbox as they expand our platform further into their enterprise customer base and into new geographies for Docebo including APAC countries where Darwinbox is growing rapidly. As Claudio noted, innovation will remain a critical part of why we win. In H1 2024, we will be providing better access to Learn Insights, a comprehensive and modern analytics experience with a new generation of customizable dashboards embedded into Learn LMS. This will provide increased data visibility and analytics engagement for our customers. Learn Insights utilizes Snowflake and AWS QuickSight to deliver advanced filtering, drill down and sharing features that can be fully customized to meet the needs of different use cases for which a customer is using our platform.We will also be launching learner communities this year, a module that enables customers to create and activate around digital community where they can seamlessly embed and integrate into their learning capsules. Later this year, we will release several exciting new AI capabilities. Docebo Shape will be enhanced and monetized with a new chatbot interface powered by Gen AI. This integration brings improved AI content generation capabilities to our amazing product. The AI creation add-on now supports the vertical page outputs in addition to horizontal slide formats. In addition, we will be launching a new virtual role play technology showcased during our last Docebo Inspire. It is currently in beta and will be available for early access in April and general availability in late quarter 3 2024.This product offers a video-based role-play learning experience for sales enablement and has potential for other use cases like customer support and onboarding in the future. It will be sold to customers on an annual licensing model. In conclusion, I want to express my gratitude to the global Docebo community for their support and contributions to a highly successful 2023 for Docebo. As we look to 2024, we will continue to focus our execution on these 5 pillars of growth. Number one, continue to lead in the external use case, large greenfield opportunity for Docebo. Number two, expand our presence where we will continue to grow our base of enterprise customers worldwide. Number three, introducing our robust learning platform to the lucrative and underserved government sector.Number four, gearing up our partnerships with strategic partners throughout the year. Number five, improving our expansion meaning upsell and cross-selling efforts with our current customers. Our goal is to achieve growth by consistently and methodically executing our plans. We're dedicated to promoting innovation and using it as a crucial factor in our success. By leveraging innovation, we aim to distinguish ourselves from our competition and constantly enhance our products and services to meet the changing demands of our customers.With that said, I would like to hand the call over to Sukaran.
Thank you, Alessio, and good morning, everyone. For those interested, a detailed breakdown of our financial results for the 3 months and fiscal year ended 31st December 2023 can be found in our press release, MD&A and financial statements, which are now available on our website and are also filed on SEDAR and EDGAR. Subscription revenues were $46.5 million representing 94% of total revenue for the quarter and an increase of 28% from the prior year. Total revenue for the fourth quarter grew to $49.3 million, an increase of 27% from the prior year and exceeded our guided range. Annual recurring revenue at the close of Q4 was $194.3 million, an increase of 24% or 23% after adjusting for the positive impact of approximately 1 percentage point given the weakening of the U.S. dollar relative to other foreign currencies.We added 80 net new customers in Q4 and ended the quarter with a total of 3,759 customers, an increase of 11% year-over-year. Average contract value was approximately $52,000 for the fourth quarter, an increase from $49,000 in the third quarter of 2023 and an increase of 12% year-over-year. The growth in average contract value is being driven by our continued expansion into the enterprise customer segment with average contract value of $100,000 and above. Net retention for the year came in at 104%, down from the prior year. Gross retention remained relatively flat compared to the prior year and gross profit margin for the fourth quarter improved by 40 basis points year-over-year to 81.2% of revenue and was relatively consistent with the prior quarter. Total operating expenses for the fourth quarter increased to $38.9 million from $31.5 million in the prior year period.G&A as a percentage of revenue decreased to 17.4% for the fourth quarter compared to 17.9% for the third quarter of 2023. We expect G&A expenses to continue to drive operating leverage while remaining relatively flat in absolute dollar spend. Sales and marketing expense as a percentage of revenue was 32.8% for the fourth quarter compared to 34.9% for the third quarter. Our investments in IT systems and workforce optimization have resulted in improved productivity and efficiency leading to improvements in our sales and marketing efficiencies. R&D investments in the fourth quarter were $9 million or 18.3% of revenue, a decrease from $10.3 million for the third quarter. As a result, adjusted EBITDA was $6.5 million for the fourth quarter of 2023 or 13.2% of revenue, above our guided range of 10% to 10.5% of revenue.We reported net income of $3.2 million for the fourth quarter of 2023 compared to $1.6 million for the fourth quarter of 2022. Adjusted net income for the fourth quarter of $8.3 million compared to $3.4 million for the fourth quarter of 2022. We generated positive free cash flow of $7 million or 14.2% of revenue compared to 18% for the third quarter of 2023 and 5.1% for the fourth quarter of 2022. In addition, as part of our NCIB and SIB programs, during the fourth quarter we repurchased approximately 2 million common shares for cancellation at an average price of $47.90 for the total cash consideration of $108.2 million, which includes transaction costs. Share-based compensation accounted for 3.3% of fourth quarter revenue compared to 2.8% in the fourth quarter of 2022. More importantly, net dilution impact for fiscal year 2023 was less than 1%.Now for our Q1 2024 outlook where our guidance is above the Street's consensus for both the top and the bottom line. Here are the key takeaways. We expect total revenue to range between $51 million to $51.3 million. We expect gross margin to range between 81% to 81.5%. We expect adjusted EBITDA margin to range between 12.5% to 13.5%. A few additional points to note in regards to our first quarter guidance. We expect subscription revenue to be about 1 percentage point higher than overall company revenue while professional services to remain relatively flat sequentially from Q4. This is being driven by our increasing work with system integrators who are a critical part of both expansion into the large enterprise accounts and the government business, which is fed and SLED.Before turning the call over for Q&A, I would like to highlight several key points as we enter this new year. First, our top priority remains growth and we aim to position the company to consistently deliver profitable growth regardless of the economic cycle. We are successfully pursuing a balanced approach to growth and profitability by expanding our adjusted EBITDA margins and we will continue to invest in our AI road map and expanding our go-to-market teams, including government-related cost to achieve FedRAMP compliance. Second, we anticipate continuing to show operating leverage and achieving an adjusted EBITDA of approximately 15% for the full fiscal year 2024.That concludes my prepared remarks. Operator, please open the line so that we can take questions from the analysts.
[Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from Ryan MacDonald with Needham.
Congrats on a great quarter. Maybe to start on just the strong execution in the quarter. Lots of great new customer wins with a Top 4 U.S. financial services company, some great expansion. Curious as you're looking at sort of the pipeline and maybe some of the success in fourth quarter, what you're seeing sort of drive that in terms of improved execution and productivity from the direct sales force versus some additional benefit from the growing SI channel relationships and how you see that sort of balance in the pipeline looking into 2024?
Ryan, thank you for the question. Alessio speaking, I'll take your question. So a few things on the enterprise motion. The 1 thing that I'd like to emphasize is that as we mentioned in prior calls, one of the big factors for us has been maturing our execution by demonstrating value at the point of sale. The way we do this today is a lot better than we used to do it 1 year ago. How do we do it? It's the value engineering methodology and team that is fully ramped in the company. This has helped us achieve really good results with logos that we closed in quarter 4. You mentioned the significant financial services organization that we won, but I would also include in this upsells of the caliber of Pirelli where we had to demonstrate specific value in order to add certain use cases. As we think about the pipeline, I think our job is to continue to extract value from the business. There is a lot of greenfield available and we are really doubling down on our execution on the demand side not only with our stronger branding and marketing team execution, but also by having our sales in the territories work the territories really in a very well-co-related manner. We've been focusing on this a lot. I hope this helps.
Yes, absolutely. Maybe just as a follow-up then. Wanted to discuss sort of the OEM channel. Obviously about last month Ceridian, which is obviously a big OEM channel partner for you, acquired a business called eloomi which is the sort of MS LxP provider at the low end of the market. Obviously I think the OEM channel has been an important one for you in terms of driving growth. As you think about sort of expectations into '24, I know you're not guiding for the full year, but maybe what your sort of thoughts were in terms of the growth algorithm of how much growth you're expecting to be driven from the OEM channel this year and how that changes, if at all, in your mind now that Ceridian is sort of buying I guess a competitive solution to maybe go to market internally or more directly than through partnership going forward?
100%. So first off, let me lead by saying that Docebo and Dayforce have established a strong and enduring working relationship since becoming partners several years ago. Number two, I would say important to note, the leadership of the 2 companies are working together on this positioning that you mentioned and so we expect further discussions with them. We don't anticipate any impact that is material on revenue for fiscal year '24 at this time. And with regards to kind of other partners that we're working with. First off we continue to work on a really healthy pipeline of new OEMs. But the work that we're doing with organizations like E&Y and Darwinbox and MHR is very significant. We are seeing very good traction. We're intrigued also by the fact that Darwinbox operates in a region that for us will be strategic in the future and they're extremely focused on the APAC market so this is very good for us. Finally, I would roll into this conversation our efforts in strategic partnerships and channel in general because we're seeing the tremendous amount of traction on our sites. Look, we don't guide specifically on OEM versus other channels. But the channel in general remains a priority and a growth pillar for us in the future.
Ryan, I was just going to jump in just to clarify that from our perspective, like Alessio said, we do not anticipate any material impact to revenue in FY 2024 and we are comfortable with how the consensus has been built.
Your next question comes from Rob Young with Canaccord Genuity.
I know that you added $12.5 million of ARR on only 80 customers and so I want to dig into that trend. Is there any underlying churn there? Because it seems like the average customer value quite a bit higher, I think you said $71,000 on incremental customers so there's a bit of a disconnect there. And then maybe just talk about the big jump in average customer value this quarter.
Sukaran, would you like to take this?
Yes. It's very consistent with what we spoke about in the last few quarters. If you think about the fact that we've been continuously focusing on supporting the sweet spot for us continues to be the mid-market to the large enterprise customers as well as penetrating into the government segment. We also saw a win that we noted in our press release with the Texas state win. In effect what is consistently happening as we move upmarket is that you're going to continue to see Docebo focus on stronger unit economics in the mid enterprise to large enterprise segments. And we are very strategically focused on driving sales in the SMB commercial space as we call it where we see an opportunity to grow that customer into multiple use cases and drive higher ACV, but we've spoken about this.From an overall unit economics perspective, we will invest our gross dollars to drive higher ACV in categories or in segments where we can have multiple use cases and multiple products and modules supporting those customers and that's really what's playing out here. You can kind of see in the numbers from a from a channel perspective as well, you're seeing that more enterprise and mid-market customers are participating into the growth in the last 3 quarters or so and that's pretty much what's driving the ACV higher. Of course recall that there is a small element of churn that comes through us just not supporting as much to the SMB customer. That is a lower ticket value. If it is a lower ticket value, we will try and make sure that we either extract additional value for them, but there could be some incremental churn that comes from that number, but majority of this is driving through our focus in the mid- to large enterprise customers, which you don't need the quantity, but you get the quality from an ACV perspective and higher ACV.
Okay. And then second question for me will be on the expansion with the large Big 5 technology company. It seems as though these expansions on these large deals are coming quicker and so if I'm right on that, what's driving it? Is it just better go-to-market with your cross-selling effort or is it some market function or is it consolidation? What's happening? And are you seeing this sort of cross-sell come through more quickly than in the past?
Actually I would say, Rob, that in the instance of this expansion that's relatively quick on this customer, it's not uncommon for us to uncover further needs in the initial phases of, if you will, onboarding, implementation, integration especially with large customers that have complex use cases and an organizational complexity of needs that may arise at the point of sale, but also sometimes surface after the point of sale. So we actually see this quite frequently. With that said, what we are referring to as expansion here is additional modules, right; additional modules, additional technology, additional SKUs to the existing contract and not necessarily selling into, say, subs and/or separate entities of the customer. We just essentially became even more sticky and added more technology to the original contract.
Okay. But is the trend towards faster cross-sell? Is that not a function? It seems like Bojangles this quarter, this large cut, it just seems as though you're expanding more quickly than in the past in the same customer.
It is intentional. There is more intentionality in continuing to execute on the expansion side. This is one of the, if you will, output of the work we're putting into it. As Sukaran said before, the land-and-expand strategy with the amazing customers that we have is a pillar of growth and these are a couple of good applied examples.
Your next question comes from Suthan Sukumar with Stifel.
And congrats again on another impressive quarter. The first question for me is on the government opportunity. Could you guys provide any update on kind of how you're thinking about the timelines here for full certification and the progress on the pipeline build side of things that you're able to do in the meantime? And do you guys foresee any impacts here from the U.S. election?
Suthan, I'm Alessio speaking. So we are incredibly focused on this as you may imagine. It's a big undertaking from an effort standpoint of our teams that have done an amazing job. In terms of our FedRAMP certification, which is what I think I was talking about primarily, is we're progressing really well and we are actually very optimistic in securing the sponsor shortly. We have more than 1 option to do so. And so yes, we want to surface. We're cautious yet with optimism in securing the sponsor. And why is this important? Because the pathway through a sponsorship yields a faster timeline to certification as opposed to a standard application process, which has a more delayed timeline in a matter of several months compared to the sponsored one.I would say even ahead of getting the certification though, I want to surface that we're continuing to win material business and material deals in the space more on the SLED side, state and local. And I would say in this regard working with SIs that are in the market has been critical for us. So we've mentioned in the past working with specific strategic SIs and that those collaborations are getting just deeper and deeper and spilling over to the commercial side of those same SIs. So in an interesting way, this focus on government has led us to get in deep with SIs starting from the government door, but opening up doors on the commercial side that perhaps before were not as open. And so we're reaping benefits on both sides of the equation.
Great. The second question I had was I guess more on sort of the cross-sell traction you guys have been seeing. Could you provide an update on some of the recent adoption trends you've been seeing across your learning suite and especially with some of the more recent product innovations that you launched recently like the [indiscernible] which I believe was launched during the quarter. Just kind of curious to see how that may be trending?
Sure. So in terms of adoption of technology that we've launched, I want to underscore that we really are very satisfied with the trend that we have seen with regard to Docebo Shape. Docebo Shape is priming to be a strategic technology and platform for us moving forward. We emphasized on the Shape side, the AI and Gen AI capabilities. We're pushing very much into that. Customers are liking it more and more as we improve it. I would say an example of that since you were just asking about government, we mentioned a customer win in Texas on the government side. And one of the key differentiators in that deal was Shape in order to repurpose existing material that the agency had and being able to recreate content using Shape. But Shape in our view has even further opportunity, Suthan. We want to push further the content creation offering side of it and the Gen AI side, we're working very much on it.So on Shape, I would say already great results. However, the amazing stuff is yet to come. So we're incredibly bullish on that technology. We're seeing an uptick in the sale and the pipeline creation of the module Microsoft Teams, which we launched a few months ago and is starting to do really well for us. And in general, look, I would say the best answer that I can think of to your question is we continue to think about providing value to our customers and focusing on how our products meet the customers' needs. There is a concerted focus on the customer experience and understanding really where we need to do better, how we're doing better swiftly makes it into our product road map to stay on top of the market trends. That's a big focus we have. Yes, we're becoming bigger, but we don't want to lose that agility and nimbleness of being able to continue to improve our product for our amazing customers. That is a priority that we have now and we're going to continue to have in the future.
And 1 quick point, Suthan, just I want to add to that is that if we look into 2024, then we'll provide some more color as we implement some of the changes. But as we go to market and position Docebo, you can expect that as we package the offering to our customers, it would be more around features and capabilities of the problem we solve for them rather than the individual products and modules that historically we place with the customer. So as we look at opening different packaging and pricing optionality for our customers, we also think that that will help not only ease our ability to sell increased deal velocity, but also make sure we sell from -- most importantly make sure we sell from a perspective of driving value and solving the problem for the customer. And so that's going to be certainly 1 other area as we think about modules going forward.
That's great. Thank you, gents. Appreciate the color and congrats again on the quarter. I'll pass the line.
Your next question comes from Josh Baer with Morgan Stanley.
I was hoping you could talk a little bit about the competitive landscape just thinking about the legacy LMS vendors. Is the competitive environment getting easier, tougher, staying the same? And then I have a follow-up.
A couple of comments from my side on competitive landscape. No notable changes or something very new that changes our views on our strategy in general. Notably on the customer wins that we have executed this time in this quarter, I would say the bank that we referred to, I think in the script we indicated that they felt like their system was outdated. We continue to see a trend that we have described before where especially large organizations that have providers with overlapping assets constitute an opportunity for us to be crisp and clear in our value proposition and offering. And as a result, stand out and clear that confusion and come in with a very well-defined value prop and in that case, there was a big strength that we've leveraged. We believe we have much more opportunities to do the same thing across some of the best companies that have that same issue.The other trend that is the opposite of competition, the lack of competition we're seeing in the external use case side. It's a very big greenfield opportunity. Pirelli that we've mentioned in our script for example was an expansion that allowed us to win the business of partner training. Now this technology was built in-house, was not competitive before. Why? Because as we've mentioned before, the business of external training oftentimes is still greenfield and so we love that because it makes our job a little bit easier in a way; but yes, definitely less competitive. And then the non-enterprise markets remain noisy. There are a lot of small vendors. And in general, the SMB space tends to be a race to the bottom space in terms of pricing. And that is also one of the reasons why we remain focused on higher value ACV and more complexity given the capabilities of our product.
Got it. Really helpful. And kind of my follow-up was around the different market segments, I think you answered it for SMB. So maybe just like thinking about your evolution as a company and maybe thinking about enterprise versus mid market or upper mid market like where are you prioritizing your resources? And when you think about sales reps going after opportunities like how are they balancing the potential to land bigger with like a broader LMS deployment versus potentially landing for a specific use case or a single department like balancing that versus bigger displacement opportunity?
Sure. So Sukaran, please chime in with any additional considerations, but I have a couple of points to this question. Historically, Josh, as you know, we have been quite balanced in our approach to small, mid-market and enterprise segments. Over the past few years, we have taken a position such as that our product capabilities and our differentiation in our platform lead itself to being more appreciated by organizations that are not necessarily small or big per se, but has more complexity of use cases meaning they have more jobs to be done. This can happen in a very large bank, but it can also happen in a relatively small relative to size association. But that doesn't mean that that association doesn't have the complexity of need that we are able to satisfy that yields eventually in a high ACV. So the first thing I'd like to note is not always the employee size is the driver of the complexity and therefore, the value that we can both offer and extract.Secondly, you asked where we are diverting more our efforts and resources. We're certainly focused on building a platform that scales, that is secure, that is stable and high performing in highly complex environments. I'm speaking about concurrency, I'm speaking about high volume of users. And look, we recognize that the LMS market per se is in theory competitive. But when you really look at the players that can do complexity, multiple use cases and manage multiple millions of users and enable learning as a business at scale, allowing and unlocking millions and billions of revenue; there are not too many that can do that. And so we're diverting -- we're focusing our resources and exactly becoming that 1 player platform company that solves everything for learning technologies, for learning in general and become a partner of the company as opposed to the LMS tool. We want to be seen as a strategic partner and not just as a commoditized technology.
And Josh, the only thing I want to add quickly to Alessio's point is that it's obvious, I'm sure you're seeing this across the board. Ultimately in the decision-making process, that's been also an effort and change as we -- not change is the wrong word, but have improved our motion in the last couple of years as more C-suite and the scrutiny. What that effectively really means is that you do get an opportunity more than you used to even in the past where you can potentially consolidate the tech stack at the onset. But we are more than happy depending on scenarios of each customer to start with a certain use case or multiple use cases and build over time. One of the strategies that we do where we can't consolidate the tech stack at the onset is that we will continuously track -- and I don't want to give all of our strategies.But just some perspective is that we will track as all of our mid-market enterprise customers our opportunity based on use cases and we will work hard to win the hearts of those departments beyond the ones that we serve today. So I think the reality is when this market consolidating the tech stack in multiple use cases and leading from the ones that drive revenue and protect revenue for an organization gives us a prime seat to do so. And that's the theme that's playing out there as well as I'll say that the big win in the major bank is also a theme that is worth considering in the competitive landscape that the legacy technologies are now becoming a burden for certain organizations that are focused on driving productivity, but also employee experience.
Josh, Claudio speaking. I don't know if you remember me, I'm the former CEO, I'm kidding. I want to add 1 point to what Alessio and Sukaran were saying. I want you to understand 1 important element, which is the competition barrier we have is very sophisticated and complex use cases. But why we have this advantage? Because to build an horizontal LMS that plays in multidepartment, certified FedRAMP, but can scale on millions of users, it's like a 5-, 7-year job. And if I was an entrepreneur and wanted to make money quickly, I would build a vertical LMS that cover on 1 use case and I will not change Docebo because it's too complex and it's too risky. And remember that this company is 18 years and 11 months old.So we get there because of the luxury of time we had to stay in the market and prosper on the market and also because we have worked with transformational customers like Thomson Reuter, Banca Intesa, Amazon AWS that over time added requirements that were very complex. So if I have to imagine what is our strongest role to protect Docebo fortress is our complexity that makes it unappealing for competitors to chase very sophisticated environment. On top of that, competitors that are there are not innovating fast enough. So we have also the innovation that plays on our advantage. If you sum those two, you will see the competition pressure on both sides, but we have these big stocks of very large and complex cases, which is very hard to change.
Your next question will come from Kevin Kumar with Goldman Sachs.
I wanted to start just maybe asking about overall macro trends that you're seeing. How are enterprise sales cycles trending? And when you talk to your customers, how are they talking about just overall kind of learning development budgets for '24?
So I'd say from enterprise trends, we continue to see some form of elongation in the processes and the trends that we've mentioned in the past haven't changed too much although we're seeing in some sectors more than others some positive signals. But we remain cautious in our position around sales cycles specifically. In terms of trends that we're seeing, of course very naturally everybody knows that Gen AI is a very critical trend that everybody talks about. What I'm seeing in this area if I have to say something that stands out more than others is a big desire to be educated. I think we are in a phase in which 2024 will be the big year of education and realization relative to L&D. education a realization of the art of the real possible and how to get to real value. Perhaps the past few years many have either used Gen AI as a core capability to strengthen certain capabilities of the platform.In other instances, it has been used more as a marketing leverage. From our perspective, Gen AI has always been an investment and the way we respond to that, right? From our perspective, Gen AI has been a huge investment in the core of our system with different features that make adoption easier and faster. And now that we're focused even more on Shape, it's creating incremental value which we spoke to with our road map on the creation side in particular. I think the additional element that I can speak to is L&D leaders are very concerned, remain very concerned with the topic of skills transformation. We see all the time going into projects in which there is a desire to upskill and train workforces whether it's exiting workforces or entering newer generational workforces. The attention to managing skills, which for us translates the business problem is this one.How we resolve it and how we approach it is by helping customers translate very complex ontologies of skill sets in the platform actually using AI. We have a very sophisticated technology to do that and our customers are finding a ton of value in it. I think Gen AI and skills management are the macro trends. There is also a palpable sentiment of how Gen AI in itself will change the content world and whether the business of content will be disrupted by adoption of Gen AI. We know the capabilities of those technologies and learning leaders really debate this a lot. And our role in all of this is to be part of that education system that guides customers and leads them and helps with the technology that we have or that our partners can offer.
Appreciate the color. Really helpful. And then maybe just 1 on net dollar retention, I think that dropped a bit in '23. So maybe if you could help dissect that number a bit. Did churn kind of impact that or did the rate of expansion slow a bit and I guess how are you thinking about kind of like a range or a sustainable retention rate for the business going forward?
Sure. Sukaran, do you want to?
Yes, will do. So net retention, I think the way I would kind of speak to this year is generally it's a bit of a consistent trend you're probably seeing across the macro. But what's baked into our net retention at a high level just to kind of give you some macro points here specific to Docebo is that the cautious spending and we talked about some of the deliberate move that we've made in the past 2 years around mid market to enterprise. So if you combine cautious spending and the SMB space impact in 2023 as well as just general macro trends from a seat compression or flat seat compression especially on the internal use case side, I think those 2 factors combined is where net retention kind of was.I would say that as we always are frank, this is an area where we will call out ourselves as a management team will be one of our important focus areas as we move forward. We'll certainly look to improve this as we move into 2024, 2025 cycle. But I think what's important to also remember is that from a gross retention perspective, our gross retention was relatively flat year-over-year, slightly below. But where we continue to participate in mid- to large enterprise customers, expand multiple use cases and as we look to pricing and packaging these more effectively into the latter part of this year, you should expect us to not only be focused on driving healthy expansion opportunities not just from a cross-sell perspective, but more from an upsell perspective.And then we of course have a number of new products that we spoke about at Docebo Inspire in Q3 of last year that will kick in whether it's in late H1 and H2 of this year. That will show some more meaningful impact I would say as we look into 2025, but some impact in 2024 as well. But combining the use case expansion, new products and modules and the new packaging that we're doing; I think in a nutshell what we'll say is that while the macro is what it was and it certainly has some pressure on seat expansion and cautious spending in the lower end of the market, I think we're going to be highly focused in driving this avenue of growth as we look into '24, '25.
Your next question comes from Richard Tse with National Bank Financial.
I'm kind of curious to see the business has changed a bit in terms of I think you're moving up market to higher value customers. What is the mix of new wins from direct versus partners and how would that have changed year-over-year?
Sure. I will pass it to you, Sukaran.
So Richard, I think in terms of overall what's changed as we looked over the years. Generally I think we've talked about on the growth side, the bigger shift that Alessio spoke at the start of the call was that if you can remember, I know you've been following the company since the start of time, when we went public. At that time, the company from an even source attribution perspective was heavily inbound and there was a certain element of outbound from a partner SI perspective. That was a very different motion compared to if you look at 2023, you would say that to be able to be successful in the mid-market and enterprise segments, we've successfully transitioned or we've done as best as we can and continue to work hard on transitioning more robust outbound motion significant investments, as you know, from our partners; the ones that we called out, whether it's in the OEM channels or whether it's the E&Y or our partner channels [indiscernible] especially E&Y that we signed as well as other SIs that we work with in the government space. Carahsoft is the one we named that is a significant partner to us in winning some of the business and driving some of the pipeline in the government space.We have significant SIs that have helped us win deals such as the large big tech opportunity that we just closed in Q3. I think that shift combined with the heavy investments that we have made over the last 2.5, 3 years that drive our ability to sell in a mature organized fashion into large enterprise customers combined with of course and the most important point is the technology that is not just innovative, but a technology that has to remain robust and perform at the level that is expected by the Fortune 500s of this world. I think that is overall the winning formula here and for us, the game is pretty straightforward. We understand what our product does, where we can support our customers and the use cases that can drive ROI for them. Our job is to just keep our heads down and continue to focus on channels and source the attribution that will drive not only new business, but expansion of the current business by making sure that we do that in an efficient fashion from a CAC perspective.
Okay. And just a related question to that. It seems like you've certainly become a lot more efficient. So in that context with everything you're doing here, what's the order of magnitude in terms of the change that you've picked up on the LTE to CAC side. My guess is that it's improved, but can you give us a sense of the degree of that improvement?
Yes. It's certainly significantly improved. I would say that it's -- I want to just underscore some things around the margin profile and I'll come back to CAC in a second. I think one thing that I want to highlight though, Richard, that's important to note is that our investments whether it's R&D or sales and marketing on a relative basis remain the same. The biggest impact that you're seeing firstly from an operating leverage, which is pretty obvious, is that as the business is scaling; we're a 81% gross margin business; you're going to see the 1 area that we've always said all along, G&A continue to give operating leverage to the business. On the sales and marketing side, as you think about the fact that 2023 was a year where we had higher quota capacity, more major investments in technology where we upgraded our CRM order to cash process as well as the fact that the attrition levels are nowhere near the madness that was going on in 2020-'21 era.You're going to see just natural efficiencies come through the system because of those inefficiencies that have gone away that were there in 2020-'21 era. And so what I'm trying to articulate here is that growth is our primary focus and our investments in sales and marketing and R&D will remain to drive growth as the primary objective. What you're seeing in the results come through as a positive on the EBITDA side is just a natural inflection point of the business and certain nuances on how we continue to optimize in certain areas. But majority of that we will attribute to a model where we are now showing operating leverage through scale. In terms of the sales and marketing side on the LTV to CAC, you can expect that we're comfortably north of 7x to 8x in that area. But I wouldn't disclose it on a segment basis, but it's much more superior when you think about certain segments versus others.
This will conclude the question-and-answer session on today's call. I will now turn it back over to Claudio Erba for any closing remarks.
As you all know, this is my last earning call and I would like to take a minute to thank you all. I want to thank all the analysts that provide top coverage; Stephanie, Martin, Robert, Gavin, Christian, Josh, Richard, Ryan, Kevin, Suthan, Daniel, the 2 Kevins, I have learned a lot from you. I want to also thank small and big shareholders, asset managers, pension funds, hedge funds, family offices, and the individuals that invested in Docebo giving us your trust. I want to thank the Board, the executive team, and Docebo employees, partner and their families. You are now in the good hands of the best of the best, Ale supported by a rock star like Sukaran and [ Fabio ]. Thank you all.
This concludes today's conference. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.