Trican Well Service Ltd
TSX:TCW
Earnings Call Analysis
Q4-2023 Analysis
Trican Well Service Ltd
Trican Well Service reported a solid fourth quarter for 2023, maintaining performance through economic headwinds. The company's revenue increased by roughly 8% year-over-year to $254.9 million, despite facing slight pressure on adjusted EBITDA which decreased to $56.4 million or 22% of revenues from $59.4 million or 25% in Q4 of 2022. This reflects a combination of job mix variations and market challenges. Even with market fluctuations, Trican's proactive measures led to positive consolidated earnings of $28.8 million, illustrating a balance of strategic execution and cost management amidst inflationary pressures.
The balance sheet presents a picture of financial health with a positive working capital of approximately $153.2 million and cash reserves of $88.8 million. Trican strategically repurchased and canceled 22.7 million shares throughout 2023, amounting to 10% of the outstanding shares at year's start, signaling confidence in the intrinsic value of the company and a commitment to enhancing shareholder returns. The dividend policy also saw progression with an increase to $0.045 per share for the quarter, up 12.5% from the previous quarter, ensuring a consistent return of capital to shareholders while maintaining a payout range between $34 million and $36 million annually.
The company successfully completed its first pad for Petronas, reflecting Trican's strong execution capabilities and potential for continued partnership in 2024. Their cementing division ran at full capacity, holding a substantial market share, specifically commanding over 50% in key areas of the Montney, Duvernay, and Deep Basin. While the coil division seeks further growth to enhance scale and efficiency, the addition of a key salesperson from a competitor is set to impact the division positively. These operational strides underscore Trican's sustained competitive advantage and pursuit of long-term growth.
For Q1 2024, Trican anticipates a slight dip in performance compared to the previous year, subject mainly to fewer rigs in operation and lower gas prices leading to margin compression. Nevertheless, the outlook for the quarter remains positive, with the slowdown in January seen as a temporary setback. The company's resilience and ability to navigate the industry's cyclicality position it to rebound swiftly from this slowdown, continuing its trajectory of delivering value to stakeholders.
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the Trican Well Service Fourth Quarter 2023 Earnings Results Conference Call and Webcast. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded. I would now like to turn the meeting over to Mr. Brad Fedora, President and Chief Executive Officer of Trican Well Service Limited. Please go ahead, Mr. Fedora.
Thank you very much, and good morning, everyone. Thank you for attending the Trican fourth quarter results conference call. First of all, Scott Matson, our Chief Financial Officer, will give an overview of the quarterly results. I will then provide some comments with respect to the quarter and the current operating conditions and our outlook for the near future. And then we will open the call for questions. As usual, several members of our executive team are in the room today and are available to answer any questions anyone may have. I'd now like to turn the call over to Scott to start things off.
Thanks, Brad, and good morning, everyone. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that this conference call may contain forward-looking statements and other information based on current expectations or results for the company. Certain material factors or assumptions that were applied in drawing conclusions or making projections are reflected in the forward-looking information section of our MD&A for Q4 2023. A number of business risks and uncertainties could cause actual results to differ materially from these forward-looking statements and our financial outlook. Please refer to our 2023 annual information form for the year ended December 31, 2023, for a more complete description of business risks and uncertainties facing Trican. This document is available on our website and on SEDAR. During this call, we will refer to several common industry terms and use certain non-GAAP measures, which are more fully described in our Q4 2023 MD&A. Our quarterly results were released after close of market last night and are available both on SEDAR and our website.So with that, let's move on to our results for the quarter. Most of my comments will draw comparisons to the fourth quarter of last year, and I'll provide a few comments about our quarterly activity and expectations going forward. Trican's results for Q4 were as anticipated, essentially in line with last year's Q4 with slightly more activity muted a bit by inflationary pressure and impacted by the standard Christmas break, which lasted pretty much through the end of the year. Revenue for the quarter was $254.9 million, an increase of about 8% compared to Q4 of 2022 and adjusted EBITDA came in at $56.4 million or 22% of revenues, down slightly from the $59.4 million or 25% of revenues we generated in Q4 of 2022. This was mainly attributable to our job mix in the quarter based on the specific well designs and customer programs that we executed during the quarter. Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter came in at $58.8 million or 23% of revenues, again, essentially in line with the $60.1 million or 25% of revenues we printed last year. To arrive at EBITDA, we add back the effects of cash settled share-based compensation recognized in the quarter to more clearly show the results of our operations and remove some of the financial noise associated with changes in our share price as we mark-to-market these items. On a consolidated basis, we continued to generate positive earnings, printing $28.8 million in the quarter, which translates to about $0.14 per share basic and 13% per share on a fully diluted basis. We generated free cash flow of $38.7 million during the quarter as compared to $47.1 million in Q4 of 2022. Our definition of free cash flow is essentially EBITDA less nondiscretionary cash expenditures, which includes maintenance capital, interest, cash taxes and cash settled stock-based compensation. And as we have previously noted, we moved into a net taxable position in 2023, which is the primary driver of the year-over-year difference. You can see more details on this in the non-GAAP measures section of our MD&A. Capital expenditures for the quarter totaled $18.3 million, split between maintenance capital of about $8.8 million and upgrade capital of $9.5 million. The upgrade capital is dedicated mainly to our ongoing Tier 4 capital refurbishment program and the electrification of ancillary frac equipment, which Brad will touch on later. Updates to our fifth Tier 4 fleet were largely completed in the fourth quarter with final commissioning occurring early in Q1, and that equipment is now deployed and operating. The balance sheet remains in excellent shape. We exited the quarter with positive working capital of approximately $153.2 million, including cash of $88.8 million. And I would note that a portion of that cash balance will be used to satisfy our 2023 tax obligations and will flow out in Q1 of 2024. Finally, with respect to our return of capital strategy, we repurchased and canceled 2.6 million shares under our NCIB program in Q4 of 2023. On an annualized basis in 2023, we repurchased and canceled a total of 22.7 million shares at an average price of about $3.46 per share, representing approximately 10% of the shares outstanding at the beginning of last year. We've repurchased and canceled about 2.6 million shares since year-end, and we continue to be active and opportunistic with our buyback program. As noted in our press release, our Board of Directors approved a dividend of $0.045 per share for the quarter, representing an increase of 12.5% from our previous quarterly dividend. This essentially offsets the reduction in share count as a result of the company's ongoing NCIB program, and we'll keep our annual expected dividend payout in the $34 million to $36 million range. Distribution is scheduled to be made on March 29, 2024, to shareholders of record as of the close of business on March 15. And I would note that the dividends are designated as eligible dividends for Canadian income tax purposes. So with that, I'll turn things back over to Brad.
Okay. Thanks. My comments will include what happened in Q4, what's happening currently and what most people are interested in what we expect for the next few quarters, particularly the summer. So on the Q4 recap, overall, like as Scott was saying, it went pretty much as expected. We now expect Q4 to be slower than Q1 and Q3. As the year winds to close, more work has shifted to Q2 in these last few years, and we expect that, that will continue on, which is actually great. It keeps our staff busy throughout Q2 and then gives everybody a better Christmas break, which is appreciated by the staff in this industry. All of the pricing in each business line, we did feel a little bit of pressure. We're continuing to feel that pressure as people get any with gas prices. And particularly in Q4, there was some real aggressive pricing as people position themselves the winter. When that's happening, we typically withdraw from those situations, and we will continue to do that going forward. We believe in the value that we have to offer, and we'll make sure that it's priced accordingly. We're still in the fracturing division. We're still running with 7 frac crews. We don't think the activity is there yet to justify a need to remit crew. One of the highlights from Q4 is that we did our first pad for Petronas, which is one of the LNG Canada partners went very well. The equipment and the people performed extremely well. The customer was happy. So we expect that work to continue in 2024. On the cementing side, the results from our cementing division continue to prove our expertise and leading market position in the service line. We ran our cementing division at our absolute active capacity, which means all the equipment that we can staff. We still hold about a 35% market share in the overall basin and just over 50% in the Montney, Duvernay and Deep Basin, which is an indication of the customers looking to us for anything that technically tricky or critical. They turn to us for that service line. And of course, we're really happy with this division as a technical year. We have a great customer list, and we expect that this division will continue to perform really well in the next few years. On the coil side, we're making good progress there. As I've mentioned in previous calls, our coil division is one of those that were not that happy with just because of the scale. It's very profitable at the field level, but certainly, the scale of that operation needs to increase in order for it to generate a reasonable return on invested capital. We want to run more in the line of 10 coiled crews as opposed to 7 that we're operating today. We've added key sales person from one of our competitors who is already having a significant impact on our activity going forward. and we'll just continue to focus on that and slowly build that division.So what's our outlook for the rest of the year and for Q1 of this year? We expect Q1 of this year will be slightly lower than last year and nothing major. There's a few less rigs running. It's low gas prices, so we have had some margin compression. It will still be a really good quarter, probably won't match up to last year. We had a really slow start in January. It seemed like the Christmas break seem to extend past new years. And then just as we were ready to start, we were hit with some brutally cold weather, which lasted for about a week. And so we really didn't get started until the second half of January, which is slow. Normally, it starts much before that. And then for February and March, we're completely booked very, very busy, limited only by weather. So we expect to have a good quarter just due to the slow start in January, we're probably slightly behind last year. And where do we see 2024, again, I think it's going to be a good year, but it probably won't measure up to last year just due to the fact that we've had some disappointment in the natural gas prices over the last 2 months. And what does that mean? We've had some work move out of Q1 and pushed into the summer as people are looking for better gas prices and lower water heating costs. We've had very little in the way of outright cancellations, but we do expect drought conditions that are present in much of Western Canada to cause some water restrictions this summer.We will have to turn more to produce water or recycled water. And as we've talked about in the past, we have an extensive portfolio of chemicals to deal with this exact scenario. So we're excited to put sort of our technical chemistry to work this year. About 70% of our frac chemistry supports non-potable water, which is basically means like produced or affluent or recycled water. And about 60% of our customers make use of nonpotable water in their fracturing operations. And we would say overall on an annual basis, about 40% of the water we pump is nonbottle. So even though we do expect restrictions, we think we're going to fare very well throughout that in our chemical offering. I think will prove to our customers that it's well worth looking into. So we are expecting some choppiness this summer just due to gas prices. The strip for gas is good in the winter, but it's fairly soft in the summer. And any time there's any unease in the market, you do expect some margin compression. That's normal. We still think that Montney will be the focal point of activity. The Duvernay is building momentum, very, very frac-intensive and it's oil and liquid space, so that won't be affected by gas pricing. We think that our equipment fleet is very well suited for the Duvernay, our fifth fleet that just came out, was built specifically with the Duvernay in mine. It's heavy duty, high-horsepower pumps built to pump at high pressures for long periods of time. And so we will actively market that equipment fleet with the Duvernay customers as it's now ready and operating in the field. We are expanding our cementing services into the Clearwater into the heavy oil with some of the ground that we gave up just due to the staffing shortage in 2020 and 2021, but I think we'll build that market back on. In general, I would say the supply chain is operating still at capacity. We're still very careful to manage, especially things like third-party trucking and sand supplies into Northwest Alberta and Northeast BC. That supply chain has been playing catch-up for the last few years. And so we'll actively manage that going forward. On the strategy side, even though we expect we could have a choppy summer, we still think Canada is a great place to do business. We love this basin going forward. We expect it to be a growth avenue for us. Just in the Montney alone, LNG drilling activity has been very active. That facility is expected to come on stream early next year. So all the players there are active, making sure that they have the production required. Trican has the balance sheet to allow us to continue executing our strategy going forward. We actually look forward to times of volatility. We're uniquely set up to take advantage of any pauses or choppiness in the market. And we're certainly not concerned about anything from a gas price perspective, as we expect it's going to be short-lived. And we're actually looking forward to taking advantage of any opportunities that may come up. Frac intensity on a per well basis is still increasing. Large sand volumes, lots of stages. We expect over 8 million tons of sand to be pumped in Canada this year, and that's in comparison to just over $6 million in 2021. So sand is something that we're still actively managing. We've talked about our logistics perspectives on how we're going to deal with these increased volumes going into Northeast BC. And so we're still looking at investing in that side of the business, and it's another way that we think will differentiate ourselves. And as we said before, differentiation and modernization is the key to our strategy. We have state-of-the-art equipment. We're upgrading our systems. We have indigenous partnerships in Northeast BC, all of which makes for a very profitable and sustainable business. We still have the most efficient fracturing fleet in Canada. I think up until recently, we've displaced over 50 million liters of diesel with our Tier 4 equipment. So that's something that's been very well received by our customers, and we expect that will be the standard technology in the Montney going forward. We run 5 of the 9 Tier 4 fracturing fleets that are active in Canada today. So we're very fortunate to have had a 2-year head start in that technology. And recently, another one of our differentiation strategies has been with the electric ancillary equipment. We're the only pumping company in Canada that has electric frac equipment. And when you combine this with the Tier 4 technology, we get over 90% nature, 90% not diesel displacement with natural gas. So it's very well received by the customers. It's actually something that we could continue to focus on this year, and we expect to build out our capacity on the electric side in the next few years. It's operationally very efficient uses less people. We expect less R&M with the equipment, and it's something that we definitely intend to focus on.On the shareholder return of capital side, our priority is still to build a resilient, sustainable and differentiated company going forward. It's gone very well over the last few years. We'll look for any blips in the market to take advantage of any M&A opportunities that present themselves. And other than that, we'll just continue to focus on our strategy and deploy our equipment, particularly into Northwest Alberta and Northeast BC. We're still very active in our NCIB. Like we purchased just under 23 million shares last year. We've continued to be active every day in the market in 2024 year-to-date, and we'll continue to go forward with that. On the dividend side, as Scott mentioned, we've had a small increase, which just offsets the share reduction due to the NCIB and the record date is March 15, payable at the end of the quarter. I think I'll stop there, and we'll go to questions.
We will now begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions]. The first question comes from Aaron MacNeil with TD.
It's been pretty warm lately, but also pretty I haven't seen anything in terms of road bans on the Alberta website. But how do you think road bands might impact Q1 and Q2 this year? You mentioned the drought conditions will that impact the pace of activity. Maybe just an update on external factors that are positive or negative?
Yes. This time of year, there's always broadband concerns. And certainly, yes, it's been a warrant Q1. There's very little snow up north. And so yes, you can have 10 to 10 bands on, but that's quite typical for this time of year. There's certainly a lot of work booked for the rest of February and into March. And so in the Q2 work is always dealing with road bans and bonding roads and staging sand and water in advance. I would say the difference now that we're seeing this year that we haven't seen in prior years is that you're seeing customers actually start to really think about how they're going to be managing water months in advance. And so these have had to worry about that before. And so you're starting to see the rentals of on-site rings or the big swing pools on location, all of that market is extremely active. So it's nothing new. I think the industry continues to get better at sort of long-term planning. And I think with this growth that we've had for the last couple of years, people will just think about water sort of 3, 4 months in advance instead of 3 or 4 weeks in advance. And it's really important to note that the activity in Northeast BC is mostly produced and recycled water. There's not a ton of freshwater used up there. So just because there's water restrictions doesn't mean that the completions activity is severely impacted. There's lots of ways to work around this problem. And of course, if we get a bunch of rain in May and June, like we usually do, that will alleviate a lot of these concerns.
You mentioned the aggressive pricing in Q4. Has that continued into Q1? And I know you're not going to participate in competitive bids, but is that starting to impact your utilization as you get undercut on pricing? Like how should we think about that?
No. Our utilization has remained really high with the exception of the first half of January. Yes, every time the market flinches, there seems to be some nervousness that goes around, but we're one of the few companies that has a long-term customer list. And so we're fortunate. We as a 28-year-old company. We've had many of our customers for 10-plus years now. So we're not looking for a new customer list every quarter like some of our competitors are. And so we tend to be somewhat insulated by that activity. But yes, we don't feel the need to chase it. We don't have covenants to meet. We're well ahead of the refurbishment of our equipment into the Tier 4 technology. So we're in a really fortunate position. We're able to sit back and sort of look at how we're going to take advantage of these times in the market. And if the quarterly results are down a little bit, still be it. We run this business for the long term, not the short term. And fortunately, we're not sort of impacted by short-term financial volatility.
The next question comes from Keith MacKey with RBC.
So Brad, you mentioned you're going to stick with 7 active fleets. And you've still got 5 potential fleets in the yards that you've talked about historically. How do you think about this excess capacity, given you see the market to be relatively stable in Canada for the next few years, a sentiment we would certainly agree with. Just how do you think about that excess capacity? Is there any opportunity to rationalize and use that to improve margins over time? Or do you think you'll potentially still need that capacity? Or just how are you thinking about it in light of the market of today?
Yes, it's both. We have been rationalizing our equipment fleet, and that's just the really old equipment that was left that was left. We're fortunate A lot of the really old outdated and equipment was taking care of a few years ago now prior to me joining, and so we were in a great position from a selling equipment perspective. So yes, we've rationalized a little bit of equipment, and we will always continue to do that. But we do generally believe that a good majority of that spare capacity will come online. And so we're happy to have it sit there until we're ready to bring it out.
And maybe add one other thought, Keith, that as we went through our Tier 4 refurbishment program over the last few years, we effectively took gear off the fence upgraded that gear put it in the field and displace the existing operating stuff. So the stuff that we've actually got parked and our spare capacity is actually quite fresh and ready to go. So as we look forward a few years as industry activity will likely pick up. We'll be able to easily respond to that incremental demand when it comes. So that capacity is still in pretty good shape and doesn't require CapEx to spend to get it going again.
Yes, fair enough. And just secondly, we've seen a few budget cuts from Canadian producers recently what impact do you see direct or indirect on your outlook for market fundamentals for your services as a result of some of these cuts? And certainly, it might change if we continue to see more, but overall, things look to be relatively stable or up a little bit from last year in terms of a total CapEx spending perspective, but we have seen some of those cuts recently. So how significant of a risk do you see this as to your business in terms of financial results differing materially year-over-year or just generally the tightness in the market?
Well, just like I think we said in the comments, we've changed our perspective. On the last call, I would have said we would have expected an increase in activity in 2024. And now I would say we would expect a decrease in activity compared to 2023. How significantly, I don't think that significantly, but I think it's a little early to tell in the budget cycle for 2024. Parties says any time there's a downturn, it's the perfect time to increase your investment. So how will it impact us? No, I mean it could prove to be some great investment opportunities. We've run the balance -- we run the company to not just sort of weather these situations, but to take advantage of them. So we have no concerns about anything other than making sure we don't miss any really good opportunities out there that may come this summer.
The next question comes from Cole Pereira with Stifel.
So thinking about the 2024 outlook, is it fair to say that you think maybe margins degrading year-over-year more of a factor than activity? And you talked about a slow January, but are you able to talk about how activity has been year-over-year, maybe excluding that. Does that assume any CapEx reductions will be more of a second half of 24 event similar with what Keith said.
Yes. Any time you have an activity downturn, even if it's 3%, 5%, it always impacts margins because a lot of our competitors have very different balance sheets than we do. And so they get [ angsty ]. So definitely, there will be a margin impact going forward. And I think to your point, that might be more than the overall activity change. I would say activity in the quarter, excluding January is pretty much consistent with last year. February, March of this year would be very similar to last year.
Got you. And then any updates you can provide on how you're thinking about your frac sand logistics strategy?
No update on it. And I think we will have investment in the ground and working this year.
Got it. And obviously, you're still active with the buyback, but the pace seems to be slowing a bit compared to last year despite having a bunch of cash and significant free cash flow generation shares flowing back a little bit. How are you guys thinking about the buyback relative to how active you were last year?
Well, you can't compare this year with last year without comparing the stock price and the multiples associated with those stock prices. And so we're very opportunistic in the market. So any time like last year where we had a total disconnect of market price from cash flow generation will get very aggressive.
The next question comes from Josef Schachter with Schachter Energy Research.
Brad, you mentioned that you wanted to grow your coiled tubing fleet from 7 to 10. Are there any technology changes going on like we saw in the frac fleet that building new equipment with all the latest technologies would be better than buying equipment that's out there that's working now from a competitor that's not a strong balance sheet as yourselves. Just wondering if there's an upgrade cycle in coiled tubing like we saw in the frac fleet?
Good question. Any coil that we added will come from our existing idle fleet. So we won't be purchasing any new equipment. There's not so much technology on the coil side, but there's lots of technology on the tool side. And so those go hand in hand. And so we're quite diligent in making sure that we're participating in any new technologies that would have a corresponding effect on our coil unit utilization. Just the overall frac, the changes in frac with more stages and more overall sand drives coil utilization as well. So there's no real shift changes like we've seen and with Tier 4 natural gas engines. But we're certainly looking at applying that same technology to coil as well. There's no reason why we eventually -- I mean, there's natural gas tractors that are in the market today. We're always looking for ways to reduce diesel consumption and increase natural gas consumption on location, whether it's with fracking, cementing or coil.
Okay. Second question for me. When you're having your customer discussions related to later this year and 2025 once LNG Canada comes on, are you finding that they're thinking of waiting until they see a $250, $300 handle on AECO or is it just that they know there's 2 Bcf more, there's got to be more -- if you don't have the gas, you got to drill it up. What's your thinking in the conversations you're having? And what's your thought process? Is it price sensitive? Or is it volume sensitive?
I think the answer to all of those questions is both like we've got the LNG Canada partners that would have some production requirements that need to be filled. But of course, other parties, whether they're selling into that or not, we're looking at gas prices and you've got a real differentiated we've got a summer strip that's consistent with today's prices followed up by a winter strip that's significantly higher. And so I think most of the customers that we talk to expect a much better market in 2025 and certainly, the LNG Canada partners and in no way speak for them, but I would expect they're trying to design just-in-time inventory as much as they possibly can.
This concludes the question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Fedora for any closing remarks. Please go ahead.
Okay. Thanks, everyone. Thank you for your time and attention to our company. The management team will be available today to answer any questions that you need to follow along with. So thank you very much.
This concludes today's conference call. You may disconnect your lines. Thank you for participating, and have a pleasant day.