© 2024 Alpha Spread Limited. All Rights Reserved.
www.alphaspread.com is not operated by a broker, a dealer, or a registered investment adviser. Under no circumstances does any information posted on www.alphaspread.com represent a recommendation to buy or sell a security. The information on this site, and in its related newsletters, is not intended to be, nor does it constitute, investment advice or recommendations. The information on this site is in no way guaranteed for completeness, accuracy or in any other way. In no event shall Alpha Spread Limited be liable to any member, guest or third party for any damages of any kind arising out of the use of any content or other material published or available on www.alphaspread.com, or relating to the use of, or inability to use, www.alphaspread.com or any content, including, without limitation, any investment losses, lost profits, lost opportunity, special, incidental, indirect, consequential or punitive damages. Past performance is a poor indicator of future performance.
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Intrinsic Value is all-important and is the only logical way to evaluate the relative attractiveness of investments and businesses.
Good morning. Welcome to Trisura Group's Ltd. Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2021 Earnings Conference Call. On the call today are David Clare, Chief Executive Officer; and David Scotland, Chief Financial Officer. David Clare will begin by providing a business and strategic update, followed by David Scotland [Technical Difficulty] results for the quarter and year.[Operator Instructions] I'd like to remind participants that in today's comments, including in responding to questions and in discussing new initiatives related to financial and operating performance, forward-looking statements may be made including forward-looking statements within the meaning of applicable Canadian and U.S. securities law. These statements reflect predictions of future events and trends, and do not relate to historic events. They're subject to known and unknown risks, and future events and results may differ materially from such statements. For further information on those risks and potential impacts, please see Trisura's filings with securities regulators.I'll now turn the call over to David Clare.
Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and welcome.Our business performed very well in 2021, which represented an inflection point on our path to building a leading specialty insurance company of scale. Despite the challenges of global pandemic, progress made across the organization yielded a more robust infrastructure, a more diversified earnings base, and the nascent benefits of increased scale. Our commitment to specialty lines and delivered expansion of our strategies across North America met favorable market conditions and strong adoption of our product.Premium growth in the fourth quarter continued momentum for the first 9 months of 2021, producing again our largest premiums to-date, following sequential records in Q2 and Q3. Claims experienced in the quarter and the impact of one-time items weighed on net income, which fell 6% versus a strong prior year comparison. Importantly, adjusted quarterly net income grew 32% over Q4 2020 and return on equity remains strong at 19%, more impressive in the context of significant growth.Our team continues to demonstrate resilience and a healthy pipeline of opportunities as we scale an increasingly sophisticated and diversified specialty insurance platform. Results were particularly strong in Canada with 85% premium growth in the quarter supported by profitable underwriting. Momentum was sustained in the U.S. as premiums again hit a quarterly record, increasing 39% over the fourth quarter of 2020 and reaching $1 billion for the year.We observed significant premium increases in Canada. The standard was again Risk Solutions for front end arrangements and new R&D programs drove 123% rate of growth in the quarter versus 2020. Corporate Insurance continues to benefit from the hard market, growth in premiums and momentum with distribution partners produced the 46% growth over the prior period.Surety growth of 18% was strong as the business benefits from tailwinds in established line, expansion of a U.S. practice and a new home warranty segment with a full year of operation. More importantly Canadian loss ratio of 26% improved versus the 30% achieved in Q4 2020 driven by strong experience in Corporate Insurance and Risk Solution. Surety's 31% loss ratio rose versus what has been exceptional performance in the last year and was the result of a claim in contract surety. Profitability was supported by Corporate Insurance's growth in premium and a 26% loss ratio, as well as more than doubling of underwriting income in Risk Solutions.Combined ratio in the quarter was 91% compared to 87% in Q4 2020, driven by an increase in expense ratio following the change in our surety reinsurance structure, mitigated by an improvement in loss ratio. Despite a higher combined ratio and net underwriting income increased to 12% in the quarter, driven by growth in the business.Taking into account growing investment income, the Canadian platform maintained a strong 30% return on equity. With the extension of our U.S. style Fronting, our Canadian entity now generates attractive fee-based earnings to complement the heritage of profitable underwriting. We've made progress on our U.S. surety platform, adding experienced team members and local offices in Stamford, Denver, and Philadelphia. We are excited at the early potential expanding the product line we have demonstrated expertise in a geography with promising infrastructure tailwind.U.S. Fronting premium rose 39% over Q4 2020. Maturation of existing programs and new relationships drove top line. U.S. Fronting generated $293 million in gross premiums written and $12 million in fronting fees. We recorded $26 million in deferred fee income at the end of the quarter indicative of future fees to be earned. Loss ratio in the quarter increased as a result of weather events in certain programs and fronting operational ratio increased from the cost of reinsurance on non-scaled programs.Importantly, we believe that the current size of impacted programs and an improved structure going forward will result in enhanced profitability. Despite market conditions driving opportunities to excess and surplus lines, we wrote $24 million in admitted premiums in quarter mitigated by slower approvals by state regulators and the longer ramp times of admitted programs, it is important to acknowledge the scale of the U.S. business.Similar to our Canadian platform, the U.S. business may exhibit seasonality making sequential comparisons less relevant than when the business was in startup mode. Annual growth potential remains strong, and we do the business on 12 month basis.In the quarter, we negotiated innovation of our life annuity reinsurance contract, resulting in the end of our participation on the contract and a one-time $3 million loss. Although we realized a loss on this today, we benefit from elimination of exposure to European interest rates, and management's focus on core North American businesses. We will continue to provide capacity for our U.S. Fronting operation.Maturation of our business and growth of our balance sheet led AM Best to increase our rating size category to 9, which ranks our platform as one of the most significant funding participants in the U.S. It is expected to support our trajectory in the years to come.The strength of our growth has also catalyzed historic levels of hiring, though we admittedly face the same difficulties in hiring that many industries are facing today. An important focus through this expansion continues to be increasing operational leverage while maintaining appropriate resources to manage and underwrite the business.Interest and dividend income increased year-over-year, the result of growth impact on our portfolio. We continue to allocate conservatively, acknowledging an uncertain environment as we navigate a transition to a post-pandemic world and the unwind of monetary stimulus. Despite these dynamics, we have defended a 3% yield on our investment portfolio.The hardening market continued through year-end, and we expect this trend to sustain through 2022, albeit at a reduced pace. The majority of our growth has been achieved through enhanced distribution relationships and new volumes. And as such, we expect to navigate any eventual rate normalization smoothly. Although access in surplus markets remains strong, our admitted capabilities will be important going forward.With the continued expansion of [ admitted ] platform, maturation of Canadian Fronting and the launch of a U.S. surety strategy, we have ample and attractive opportunities to grow. Following our inaugural debt issuance earlier this year, we are well-positioned to support that growth.Our platforms have become complementary sources of lead generation for one another. As we gain market share in one geography, our presence and capabilities of our companion offices provide opportunities to generate new business and service our partners in both Canada and the U.S. Increasingly diverse and fee-based earnings help reduce volatility and support access to capital. Growth and performance in Canada has been a highlight this year and is providing momentum for the enterprise beyond the profitable maturation demonstrated in U.S. Fronting.As we look to 2022, environmental, social and governance considerations are front of mind and an important part of Trisura's development. We are focused on better communicating existing initiatives, identifying areas in which there is room for improvement, and adopting best practices. We remain an insurance company in growth mode and must focus on the skills and practices that brought us to this point.We will concentrate on business lines we know, continue to underwrite conservatively and execute on detailed structuring. As we've acknowledged in the past, our business can experience volatility and severity in claims, seeing this quarter in surety. I know that we do not view the experience in the fourth quarter of indicative -- as indicative of a future trend, and we are proud of our accomplishments over the past year. We are optimistic for the years ahead.With that, I would like to turn it over to David Scotland for a more detailed review of financial results.
Thanks, David. I'll now provide a brief walk-through of some financial results for the quarter. Gross written premium was $485 million for the quarter, which reflects growth of 54% over Q4 2020. Fee income, which is primarily related to fronting fees from our U.S. operations, grew by 31% in the quarter, reflecting growth of fronted premium in the U.S.Net claims expense in the quarter was greater than the prior year, primarily as a result of growth in the business, higher claims in our surety operation and a higher loss ratio in the U.S. business. Net commissions expense increased by 91% over Q4 2020 and operating expense in the quarter increased by 56% over Q4 2020, both reflecting growth in both the Canadian and U.S. operations.Net underwriting income in Canada for Q4 was higher than the prior year as a result of growth in the business mitigated by a higher combined ratio in the quarter. Net underwriting income for the U.S. for Q4 2021 was greater than Q4 2020, largely as a result of growth in new and existing programs, as well as improved operational efficiency. This was mitigated by higher loss ratio and the impact of additional cat reinsurance purchases, which were required for a group of programs which had yet to build sufficient scale.In Q4 2021, the combined ratio in Canada was 91%, and the fronting operational ratio in the U.S. was 79%. Net investment income was greater in Q4 2021 than Q4 2020 as a result of an increase in interest and dividend income. The increase was primarily related to an increase in the size of the investment portfolio associated with growth in operations and contributions to capital from the debt offering in June 2021 and was mitigated by reduced market yields.Net gains were $3.7 million in the quarter, which were greater than Q4 2020, largely as a result of greater realized gains as well as derivative income. Income tax expense was approximately the same in Q4 2021 as Q4 2020, reflecting similar income before tax in each of those quarters. Net income generated from the reinsurance operations was lower in Q4 2021 than Q4 2020 as a result of a loss from the novation of the life annuity reinsurance contract. This event will simplify reporting of our operating results going forward.Net income for the group was $10.3 million in the quarter, which was approximately the same as Q4 2020. Results were driven by growth in the business which was offset by higher claims in both Canada and the U.S., as well as the impact of the novation at Trisura International.Diluted EPS was $0.24 in Q4 2021, which was approximately the same as the prior year. Consolidated ROE on a rolling 12-month basis was 19% at the end of Q4 2021, which was greater than the rolling 12-month ROE at the end of Q4 2020. Assets in the year-to-date period grew by $1.3 billion as a result of growth in Canada and the U.S.Recoverable from reinsurers have increased primarily as a result of growth in the U.S. Fronting business where claims liabilities are largely offset by expected recoveries from the reinsurers to whom we see the business. Investments have grown as well, reflecting the additional capital generated as a result of the debt offering in Q2 2021 as well as capital generated from operations.Liabilities in the year-to-date period grew by $1.2 billion primarily as a result of growth in unearned premium and unpaid claims and loss adjustment expenses, which have grown as a result of growth in both Canada and the U.S. As discussed, growth in these balances is largely offset by growth in reinsurance recoverables.Equity has grown for the year by $69 million, reflecting growth in net income, as well as growth in other comprehensive income. Other comprehensive income increased in 2021, primarily as a result of opportunistic conversion of Canadian cash to fund U.S. operations.Book value per share was $8.70 at December 31, and is greater than December 31, 2020, as a result of profit generated year-to-date and unrealized gains on the investment portfolio. As of December 31, 2021, debt-to-capital was 17.3%, which has increased after the debt offering in the second quarter, but remained below our long-term target of 20%. The company remains well-capitalized, and we expect to have sufficient capital to meet our regulatory capital requirements.David, I'll turn things back over to you.
Thanks, operator. We'll now take questions.
[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Stephen Boland with Raymond James.
Two questions, maybe just about the U.S. business and the number of programs like, good addition year-over-year, but maybe you could just talk about sequentially. Did you drop any programs because I think it only went up one or were you just cautious on adding new programs?
Thanks for the question. In the quarter, we actually did drop 2 programs. One of those 2 programs were 2 that had not produced any premium in the last 6 months. So we've -- we added I think net 3 programs in the -- gross 3 programs in the quarter reduced by those 2, although again, those 2 programs were ones that just hadn't really ramped for us.
And what would cause that, David, that they obviously were looking for a market, you're providing one and they're not giving you any premium?
Yes, it's more the reception of those programs in the market. As those programs launch, some programs are going to be successful, some programs won't. And so these ones were programs that are just never reached a sufficient scale, they don't really contribute any premiums in the last few quarters and therefore they're sort of shutting down and reevaluating.
Okay. And then my second question is more a general question in terms of what's your thoughts on the ROE longer-term potential of maybe the U.S. business, we've seen the Canadian business pretty robust ROE, but overall, maybe the U.S. business and the consolidated company, is there a goal or what do you think is a sustainable ROE for your business?
Our stated goal for the business is to have a mid-teens ROE. We've outperformed that recently driven by pretty significant outperformance in the Canadian ROE. I would say the level that we've seen in Canada, we're pretty open about acknowledging that it's likely not to be sustained at that 30% level, although we do see a pretty healthy expectation for the Canadian business going forward, probably more in line with our long-term average of high teens, low 20%s.The U.S. business, I would say, in the near term, we'd expect again in the mid-teens from an ROE perspective with benefits of increasing scale, if we're successful in continuing to grow that business.
Our next question comes from Nik Priebe with CIBC Capital Markets.
I was wondering if I could ask you just to expand a little bit more on the nature of the contractor insolvency and surety in Q4? Like I'm just -- I was wondering what the circumstances were that led to that insolvency that give you sufficient comfort that this is a one-off event?
Nick, thanks for the question. It was very normal course. So contractor insolvencies can happen for a number of reasons. For the most part obviously, these contractors go insolvent for reasons of difficulties in delivering their services, working capital reasons, any host of items can drive that. For this contractor specifically, they had a bit of trouble delivering their services for factors that we don't believe are endemic or indicative of any specific trend. Unfortunately, you can in this business get contractor insolvencies, although the unique characteristics of this one really don't feed into any change in our assertion of the health of the industry or our book.
Understood. Okay. And then one other one for me, the ramp up of admitted premiums, perhaps a little bit slower than anticipated. I know in the past, you called out the more cumbersome regulatory environment, but it seems like you have made good progress on obtaining licenses and signing rates. So what's really holding that back? Is it just a product of allowing those programs to start to mature?
Yes, it's a combination of factors. I would say those that you've identified still continue to be true, although transparently, the trend in the U.S. market continues to favor excess and surplus business. So the hardening market trend that we've observed for the past 18 months continues to favor excess and surplus programs. On a submission basis, from a momentum basis in the market, we continue to see pretty healthy demand for those excess and surplus programs, which disproportionately disadvantages admitted programs. So in the fullness of time, we expect that to normalize and admitted programs to ramp up.But the state of the market today has provided us more opportunities to grow in the excess and surplus space. I would agree with you. We've been a little bit surprised by that nuance. We expected more momentum in that admitted space, although I admit the economics of these businesses between the excess and surplus lines and the admitted lines are equally attractive to us.
[Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from Tom MacKinnon with BMO Capital.
I got on the call late, but I believe you did address the contractor insolvency. The release notes something on -- associated with experienced claims associated with weather events in the U.S. Can you elaborate on that? As I recall, in the third quarter, I don't think you really had -- that's when the big weather events were happening in the U.S., and I don't think you really took any significant charge. Was there anything kind of pulled into the fourth quarter as a result of that? And then I have a follow-up.
Yes, that's a great observation. In the third quarter, we usually expect our property exposure in the U.S. to experience some level of weather impact. We didn't see that in the reported results in the third quarter. Many of the weather events that we experienced actually happened towards the end of the third quarter and that pushed the reporting of those claims into the fourth quarter.So there was a disproportionate impact from weather events in the fourth quarter. If you compare the fourth quarter's loss ratio to the third quarter loss ratio in 2020, you'll see those are much more comparable. So the impact this quarter in the U.S. really is one that's driven more by those weather events in the fourth quarter than we usually expect.
Would you be able to quantify what's the impact? And was that related to like any of the hurricanes in the U.S. as well?
So it was related to some of that hurricane activity, Hurricane Ida specifically. We haven't quantified that amount in our materials, but maybe we can follow-up offline with some estimates.
Okay. And then just as a follow-up, the loss ratio in the U.S. was up -- and I'm wondering, was there any noise associated with the cat coverage instituting that, that kind of played with that loss ratio that you disclosed?
Yes, so you're referencing the additional cat cover on sort of non-scale that you talked about.
Yes.
Yes, so there could be a marginal impact on loss ratio from those programs by -- through a reduction in net premiums earned. Although the majority of those costs come through in the commission line, there'll be a combination of impact, both on reducing net premiums earned as well as increase in commissions. The bigger impact is going to be shown in the fronting operational ratio of those programs rather than the loss ratio, although we do admit there can be a small impact on loss ratio too.
[Operator Instructions] And -- actually we do have a follow-up question from Tom MacKinnon with BMO Capital.
Yes, David, you gave some pretty good momentum with respect to the Canadian business. I'm not sure if you talked about the environment there, what you're seeing, where are you seeing the best opportunities? And are the best opportunities really with respect to the new fronting arrangements that you're instituting in Canada as well?
I would agree that the big achievement we believe this year has been the outperformance of our Canadian practice. The premium growth of that entity for the full year as well as the loss ratios that we're observing for that full year, have been a real standout for us. I would say the opportunities are pretty attractive across the board. These are relatively more mature business lines than our U.S. Fronting, for example, and continue to show pretty healthy potential.Canadian Fronting has obviously been the big standout from a growth perspective, but we don't think that the opportunity in Corporate Insurance or surety is any less attractive. That being said, the growth rates across these platforms likely don't repeat the growth rate that we've seen in 2021, although we still do believe they will be healthy in 2022.
And I'm not showing any further questions at this time. I'd like to turn the call back to David Clare for any closing remarks.
Thanks very much. We appreciate everyone joining the call today. To the extent that there are further questions, don't hesitate to reach out, and we'll end the call there.
Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's presentation. You may now disconnect, and have a wonderful day.